| Vincenzo Aiello | p | 6-1 | 190 | R | R | 1994-08-06 | Staten Island,NY | AA | -- | 2013-2021 | 2017- 28- 839-MIA
| Rider, Oklahoma |
| Tom Ambrosole | c | 5-10 | 195 | R | R | 1986 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2005-2008 | -- | Lafayette College |
| Richie Anderson | p | 6-5 | -- | R | R | 1991-10-27 | Staten Island,NY | Indy | -- | 2010-2015 | -- | College of Staten Island |
| Greg Belson | p | 5-10 | 170 | R | R | 1978-08-16 | Manhasset,NY | A+ | -- | 2000-2005 | 2000- 26- 789-ARI
| Montclair State |
| Joseph Burgund | p | 6-2 | -- | -- | -- | -- | Staten Island,NY | Indy | -- | 2016-2017 | -- | Kingsborough CC |
| Mike Campbell | p | 6-3 | 205 | R | R | 1994 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2012-2013 | -- | Rider |
| Anthony Capo | of | 6-3 | 180 | R | R | 1995 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2014-2017 | -- | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Alan Carey | p | 6-4 | 200 | R | R | 1990-05-31 | Staten Island,NY | Indy | -- | 2015-2015 | -- | Keiser, Westchester CC |
| Rich Castaldo | c | 6-0 | 215 | B | R | 1985-06-29 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2003-2006 | -- | St. Francis (NY), College of Staten Island |
| Kenny Cedel | p | 6-2 | 190 | L | L | 1987-03-24 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2006-2010 | -- | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| James Costanzo | p | 6-0 | 175 | R | R | 2000 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2019-2021 | -- | Central Conn State, Cumberland County College |
| Andrew Costello | p | 6-2 | 245 | R | R | 1987 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2006-2010 | -- | ' > Saint Peter's |
| Rob Dadona | if | 5-11 | 160 | R | R | 1996-06-24 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2015-2018 | -- | Seton Hall |
| John Desiderio | 2b | 5-7 | 160 | R | R | 1983-01-15 | Brooklyn,NY | College | -- | 2002-2005 | -- | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Joe DiBenedetto | p | 5-9 | 160 | L | L | 1995-05-25 | Staten Island,NY | A- | -- | 2014-2019 | 2017- 29- 879-TOR
| Seton Hall, Nova Southeastern |
| Dan DiGeorgio | if | 6-5 | 210 | R | R | 1998-05-05 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2018-2021 | -- | Rutgers |
| Steve Edelstein | of | 6-3 | 195 | L | L | 1996 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2015-2018 | -- | Stockton |
| John Giakas | c | 6-0 | 185 | R | R | 1994 | Staten Island,NY | Indy | -- | 2013-2017 | -- | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Michael Giuffre | 3b | 5-10 | 175 | R | R | 1990-12-14 | Staten Island,NY | Rk | -- | 2013-2013 | 2013- 36-1071-CLE
| Brookdale CC |
| Marc Goldberg | p | 5-11 | 185 | R | R | 1980 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2001-2003 | -- | St. John's, South Florida |
| Zack Granite | cf-lf | 6-0 | 175 | L | L | 1992-09-17 | Staten Island,NY | MLB | 2017-2017 | 2011-2021 | 2013- 14- 410-MIN
| Seton Hall |
| Tom Gregorio | c | 6-2 | 200 | R | R | 1977-05-05 | Staten Island,NY | MLB | 2003-2003 | 1996-2006 | 1999- 27- 821-ANA
| Troy |
| Mike Grippo | p | 5-11 | 185 | L | L | 1976-05-06 | New York,NY | A+ | -- | 1999-2001 | -- | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Ken Hagemann | 1b | 6-1 | 170 | L | L | 1961-05-25 | Staten Island,NY | A+ | -- | 1978-1980 | 1978- 7- 180-BOS
| -- |
| Robert Iacono | if | 5-7 | 180 | R | R | 1987 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2006-2009 | -- | Fordham |
| Sal Iacono | if-c | 5-9 | 190 | R | R | 1985-03-04 | Staten Island,NY | A+ | -- | 2004-2008 | 2007- 26- 801-HOU
| Princeton |
| Dennis Jackson | 1b | 6-1 | 200 | L | L | 1954 | Staten Island,NY | -- | -- | -- | 1973- 16- 374-NYN
| -- |
| Mike Knorr | ss | 5-10 | 185 | R | R | 1983-12-13 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2002-2005 | -- | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Kevin Krause | c | 6-2 | 190 | R | R | 1992-11-23 | Staten Island,NY | AA | -- | 2012-2021 | 2014- 9- 281-PIT
| Stony Brook |
| Jim Magill | p | 6-10 | 205 | R | R | 1969-03-11 | Queens,NY | A+ | -- | 1988-1993 | -- | -- |
| Anthony Maisano | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | Indy | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | St. Thomas Aquinas |
| Jason Marquis | p | 6-1 | 185 | L | R | 1978-08-21 | Manhasset,NY | MLB | 2000-2015 | 1996-2015 | 1996- 1- 35-ATL
| -- |
| Brian McDonough | p | 6-0 | 185 | R | R | 1961 | Staten Island,NY | A+ | -- | 1981-1983 | 1981- 4- 74-BAL
| Seminole Florida |
| Nick Nardulli | p | 6-0 | 190 | R | R | 1999 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2018-2021 | -- | Felician College |
| Ryan Nemoyten | of | 5-8 | 160 | R | R | -- | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2008-2010 | -- | Wagner, College of Staten Island |
| Ed Olsen | p | 6-2 | 220 | R | R | 1975-01-31 | Brooklyn,NY | College | -- | 1997-1998 | -- | ' > St. John's |
| Alan Osmundson | c-of | 5-10 | 170 | R | R | 1955 | Staten Island,NY | -- | -- | -- | 1973- 30- 655-NYN
| -- |
| Dustin Prevete | p | 6-1 | 200 | R | R | 1981 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2002-2003 | -- | Iona College |
| Raymond Rodriguez | p | 6-0 | 200 | R | R | 1983-11-17 | New York,NY | Indy | -- | 2005-2005 | -- | Central Florida, North Florida CC |
| Raymond Rudolph | ss-c | 6-4 | 190 | R | R | 1955 | Staten Island,NY | -- | -- | -- | 1973- 18- 411-MIL
| -- |
| Chris Rusciano | p | 6-5 | 205 | R | R | 1971-12-13 | New York,NY | A | -- | 1992-1997 | -- | Brooklyn College |
| Alfonse Sadallah | ss | 5-11 | 170 | L | R | 1999 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2020-2021 | -- | La Salle |
| Frank Sanacore | of-if | 5-7 | 175 | R | R | 1995 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2014-2017 | -- | New York Tech |
| Rich Scheid | p | 6-3 | 185 | L | L | 1965-02-03 | Staten Island,NY | MLB | 1992-1995 | 1985-1997 | 1986- 2- 53-NYA
| Seton Hall |
| Brandon Seltzer | of | 6-2 | 185 | R | R | 1998 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | Fairleigh Dickinson, Palm Beach Atlantic |
| Joseph Sessa | of | 6-2 | 175 | R | R | 1994 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2013-2013 | -- | Iona College |
| Nick Sessa | p | 5-11 | 165 | R | R | 1991-11-02 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2010-2010 | -- | SUNY - Albany |
| Gus Sosa | c | 6-2 | 180 | R | R | 2001-07-17 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2021-2021 | 2019- 19- 567-TOR
| Rutgers, South Mountain CC |
| Paul Stabile | p | 5-10 | 196 | L | L | 1976-01-16 | Brooklyn,NY | A+ | -- | 1997-2000 | 1997- 8- 242-PIT
| Brookdale CC |
| Michael Sullivan | p | 6-0 | 210 | L | L | 1994-01-14 | Staten Island,NY | A+ | -- | 2013-2016 | 2014- 29- 875-CIN
| Rowan-Gloucester |
| Anthony Sutter | ss | 6-0 | 185 | R | R | 1978-02-26 | Staten Island,NY | A | -- | 1999-2001 | 1997- 54-1472-NYN
| ' > Brookdale CC, St. John's |
| Rich Thoms | p | 6-0 | 180 | L | L | 1943-09-07 | Staten Island,NY | -- | -- | -- | 1965- 55- 787-BAL
| Austin College |
| Nicholas Timpanelli | p | 6-0 | 190 | -- | R | 2002 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2021-2021 | -- | Iona College |
| Vincent Timpanelli | p | 6-2 | 210 | R | R | 1998-10-02 | Staten Island,NY | AA | -- | 2017-2022 | 2020- UDFA-CIN
| St. Thomas Aquinas, Ramapo |
| Art Toal | 2b-ss | 6-2 | 183 | R | R | 1957 | Staten Island,NY | AA | -- | 1976-1980 | 1978- 11- 272-DET
| Oklahoma |
| John Toal | 2b | 5-11 | 180 | R | R | 1963-08-14 | Staten Island,NY | A | -- | 1983-1987 | 1986- 11- 266-SFN
| Oklahoma |
| Jack Tracy | of | 5-11 | 195 | B | R | 1979-08-06 | Shrewsbury,NJ | College | -- | 2001-2002 | -- | South Alabama, Brookdale CC |
| James Wise | c | 5-10 | 170 | L | R | 1998 | Staten Island,NY | College | -- | 2016-2018 | -- | Wagner |
| 58 record(s) |
