| Nick Ammirati | c | 5-10 | 185 | B | R | 1991-07-31 | Staten Island,NY | Rk | -- | 2010-2013 | 2009- 46-1388-MIA
| Seton Hall, Mississippi State, Panola College |
| Tom Ard | of | -- | -- | -- | -- | 1965 | West Orange,NJ | -- | -- | -- | 1983- 28- 697-CHA
| Northwestern |
| J.C. Ariza | p | 6-5 | 235 | R | R | 2000 | Belleville,NJ | College | -- | 2021-2021 | -- | UTRGV |
| Alex Baratta | 3b | 6-1 | 195 | R | R | 1997-01-13 | Gladstone,NJ | College | -- | 2016-2021 | -- | UNC Asheville, Binghamton |
| Ty Blankmeyer | if | 5-8 | 155 | R | R | 1993-10-12 | Morristown,NJ | Rk | -- | 2013-2016 | 2016- 36-1068-CIN
| ' > St. John's |
| Brian Bowness | 1b-3b | 6-3 | 205 | R | R | 1974-05-23 | East Hanover,NJ | A | -- | 1993-1996 | 1995- 51-1390-CHA
| Villanova |
| Tyler Brandon | p | 5-11 | 209 | R | R | 1996 | New York,NY | -- | -- | -- | -- | Maryland |
| Steven Brooks | lf-rf | 6-1 | 184 | R | R | 1989-01-26 | New York,NY | Rk | -- | 2008-2011 | 2010- 17- 520-CHN
| Wake Forest |
| Tyler Brosius | of | 6-0 | 180 | R | R | 1997-06-03 | Denville,NJ | College | -- | 2017-2020 | -- | Rhode Island |
| Mickey Brueckner | ut | 6-2 | 215 | B | R | 1983-03-16 | Madison,NJ | College | -- | 2002-2002 | -- | Seton Hall, Chandler-Gilbert CC |
| Paul Caffrey | of-p | 6-1 | 195 | R | R | 1951-01-19 | West Orange,NJ | -- | -- | -- | 1973- 2- 23-KCA
| Seton Hall |
| John Callandrello | c | 5-10 | 195 | L | R | 1987-06-06 | Montville,NJ | College | -- | 2006-2006 | -- | Seton Hall, Ramapo |
| Chris Cancro | of-1b | 6-0 | 200 | L | L | 1984-10-16 | Washington,DC | College | -- | 2004-2004 | -- | Villanova |
| Justin Cassella | if-of | 6-1 | 193 | R | R | 2001-07-02 | Bernardsville,NJ | College | -- | 2021-2021 | -- | Elon |
| Giordan Cerbo | if | 5-10 | 175 | R | R | 2000 | Montville,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | Grand Canyon |
| Nick Christiani | p | 6-0 | 195 | R | R | 1987-07-17 | Linden,NJ | MLB | 2013-2014 | 2006-2017 | 2009- 13- 389-CIN
| Vanderbilt |
| Matthew Cianci | of-if | 5-6 | 165 | R | R | 1993 | Far Hills,NJ | College | -- | 2012-2014 | -- | Fordham |
| Quincy Clark | p-of | 6-4 | 205 | R | R | 2001 | West Orange,NJ | College | -- | 2020-2021 | -- | Rhode Island |
| Evan Danieli | p | 6-8 | 225 | R | R | 1989-08-02 | New York,NY | Rk | -- | 2008-2011 | 2010- 24- 734-ATL
| Notre Dame |
| Rich Del Vecchio | p | 6-5 | 210 | R | R | -- | North Caldwell,NJ | College | -- | 2010-2010 | -- | Wagner, Rutgers |
| Joseph Demarzo | of | 5-10 | 190 | R | R | 1989 | Livingston,NJ | College | -- | 2008-2010 | -- | Bucknell |
| Nick Denicola | c | 6-0 | 203 | R | R | 1998-06-13 | East Hanover,NJ | Indy | -- | 2018-2021 | -- | West Virginia, Paris Junior College, Oklahoma State, Houston |
| Lukas Derenzi | 1b-of | 5-11 | 173 | L | L | 1995-11-04 | Morristown,NJ | College | -- | 2016-2018 | -- | Villanova |
| Michael DeRenzi | of | 6-1 | 180 | L | L | 1996 | Mendham,NJ | College | -- | 2015-2018 | -- | Georgetown |
| CJ Diana | 2b | 5-7 | 185 | R | R | 1995 | Chester,NJ | College | -- | 2014-2017 | -- | Ursinus College |
| John Dibble | p | 6-0 | 180 | L | L | 1981 | West Orange,NJ | College | -- | 2001-2003 | -- | Holy Cross |
| Bobby Dombrowski | c | 6-2 | 215 | R | R | 1987-05-30 | Denville,NJ | Indy | -- | 2007-2011 | -- | Seton Hall, Monmouth |
| Tim Dugan | p | 6-3 | 195 | L | L | 1983-03-03 | Cedar Grove,NJ | Indy | -- | 2002-2007 | -- | Fairfield |
| Eric Duncan | 3b | 6-1 | 205 | L | R | 1984-12-07 | Florham Park,NJ | AAA | -- | 2003-2012 | 2003- 1- 27-NYA
| -- |
| Jack Eichler | if | 5-9 | 160 | R | R | 2000-06-03 | Verona,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | ' > Georgia Southern, Saint Peter's |
| George Fernandez | p | 6-0 | 180 | R | R | 1990-03-02 | Union,NJ | College | -- | 2009-2012 | -- | Seton Hall |
| Luis Fernandez | p | 5-10 | 160 | B | L | 1986-09-15 | Union,NJ | College | -- | 2005-2008 | -- | Seton Hall |
| David Festa | p | 6-5 | 175 | R | R | 2000-03-08 | Verona,NJ | A | -- | 2019-2022 | 2021- 13- 399-MIN
| Seton Hall |
| Rob Fonseca | 1b | 6-2 | 205 | R | R | 1993-05-05 | Madison,NJ | Rk | -- | 2012-2015 | 2015- 21- 635-SEA
| Northeastern |
| Dan Fornaro | c | 5-7 | 160 | L | R | 1981 | Madison,NJ | College | -- | 2000-2000 | -- | Seton Hall |
| Pat Gardner | c | 5-11 | 180 | R | R | 1995 | Caldwell,NJ | College | -- | 2014-2017 | -- | Fordham |
| Joe Giovinco | if | 5-10 | 185 | L | R | 1998 | Stirling,NJ | College | -- | 2017-2020 | -- | Siena College, Gettysburg College |
| Rich Goulian | if | 6-0 | 185 | R | R | 1986 | Kinnelon,NJ | College | -- | 2005-2008 | -- | Fordham |
| Casey Grimm | of | 6-0 | 210 | L | R | 1981-02-09 | Morristown,NJ | A- | -- | 2000-2004 | 2003- 33- 995-SLN
| Seton Hall |
| Stephan Halibej | c | 6-1 | 200 | R | R | 1992-12-25 | Morristown,NJ | College | -- | 2013-2016 | -- | New Jersey Tech |
| Zach Hersh | of | 5-10 | 140 | R | L | 1997-08-29 | Livingston,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | Duke |
| Mark Hindy | p | 6-4 | 205 | -- | L | 2003 | Essex Fells,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | William and Mary |
| Tim Hoehn | if | 6-0 | 185 | R | R | 1995 | Morristown,NJ | College | -- | 2014-2016 | -- | William and Mary |
| Kieran Hollander | p | 6-1 | 190 | L | L | 2003 | Cranford,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | Ursinus College |
| Mike Hussa | c | 5-10 | 200 | R | R | 1983-12-29 | Summit,NJ | College | -- | 2003-2006 | -- | Monmouth |
| Matt Lasher | ss | 5-11 | 178 | R | R | 1968-10-05 | West Orange,NJ | A- | -- | 1989-1990 | 1989- 27- 695-CAL
| James Madison |
| DJ Link | c-3b | 5-11 | 185 | R | R | 1994 | Clifton,NJ | College | -- | 2013-2016 | -- | Harvard |
| Jack Mahala | p | 6-4 | 190 | R | R | 1999 | Far Hills,NJ | College | -- | 2018-2020 | -- | Harvard |
| Kevin Mahala | p-3b | 6-3 | 190 | R | R | 1994-07-19 | Summit,NJ | A | -- | 2014-2017 | 2016- 18- 555-PIT
| George Washington |
| Michael Mahala | p | 6-4 | 200 | R | R | 2001 | Far Hills,NJ | College | -- | 2021-2021 | -- | Navy |
| Patrick Mahala | p | 6-4 | 195 | L | L | 2001 | Far Hills,NJ | College | -- | 2020-2021 | -- | Georgetown |
| Frank Maldonado | of | 6-1 | 190 | R | R | 1995 | Short Hills,NJ | College | -- | 2015-2018 | -- | Pittsburgh |
| Nick Maldonado | p | 6-1 | 210 | R | R | 2001 | Short Hills,NJ | College | -- | 2020-2021 | -- | Vanderbilt |
| Dwayne Marshall | p | 6-2 | 205 | R | R | 1998-02-09 | Piscataway,NJ | Indy | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | Maryland-Eastern Shore |
| Javier Martinez | p | 6-2 | 220 | L | R | 1985-05-26 | Livingston,NJ | A- | -- | 2007-2008 | -- | Fordham |
| Javier Martinez | p-of | 6-1 | 185 | R | R | 1986-04-13 | South Orange,NJ | College | -- | 2004-2007 | 2007- 29- 885-SEA
| Fordham |
| Joe Martinez | p | 6-3 | 185 | L | R | 1983-02-26 | South Orange,NJ | MLB | 2009-2013 | 2002-2014 | 2005- 12- 372-SFN
| Boston College |
| Nick Mascelli | if | 5-7 | 165 | R | R | 1995-09-29 | Clifton,NJ | College | -- | 2014-2018 | -- | Wagner |
| John Masklee | p | 6-1 | 170 | L | L | 1986-10-04 | Totowa,NJ | Indy | -- | 2006-2011 | -- | Long Island-Brooklyn, Rollins, Montclair State |
| Jon McCue | p | 6-3 | 210 | R | R | 1986-11-09 | Hillside,NJ | College | -- | 2006-2009 | -- | Rutgers |
| Cole McGonigal | of | 6-4 | 220 | L | L | 2003 | Montclair,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | Pennsylvania |
| Dan Merklinger | p | 6-1 | 195 | L | L | 1985-11-19 | South Orange,NJ | AAA | -- | 2005-2012 | 2007- 6- 191-MIL
| Seton Hall |
| Ryan Messmer | p | 6-2 | 200 | R | R | 1989-12-20 | Parsippany,NJ | College | -- | 2009-2010 | -- | Youngstown State |
| Ryan Millea | p | 6-7 | 230 | L | R | 1984-11-19 | Kearny,NJ | College | -- | 2004-2007 | -- | Mt. St. Mary |
| Jeff Miller | p | 6-4 | 210 | R | R | 1980-02-01 | Belleville,NJ | AAA | -- | 2000-2007 | 2001- 15- 444-PIT
| New Orleans, Seton Hall |
| Robert Morgenroth | p | 6-4 | 210 | R | R | 1994-06-29 | North Caldwell,NJ | College | -- | 2013-2015 | -- | Bryant University |
| Nico Mottesi | of | 6-2 | 190 | R | R | 1999 | Short Hills,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | Cornell |
| Nick Natale | of | 6-1 | 175 | R | R | 1989-08-22 | Livingston,NJ | College | -- | 2008-2008 | -- | Rice, Palm Beach Atlantic, St. Petersburg College |
| Michael Ness | p | 6-4 | 205 | R | R | 1987-10-20 | Summit,NJ | A+ | -- | 2007-2013 | 2010- 33- 993-HOU
| Duke |
| John Norwood | of | 6-2 | 190 | R | R | 1992-09-24 | Peapack-Gladstone,NJ | AA | -- | 2012-2018 | 2011- 12- 379-TOR
| Vanderbilt |
| Pat O'Hare | 3b | 5-11 | 198 | R | R | 1998-03-20 | Morristown,NJ | College | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | New Jersey Tech, Siena College |
| Sean O'Hare | if | 6-0 | 190 | R | R | 1991-04-11 | Morristown,NJ | Indy | -- | 2010-2014 | -- | ' > St. John's |
| Matt O'Neill | c | 6-0 | 195 | R | R | 1997-08-20 | Morristown,NJ | A+ | -- | 2015-2022 | 2019- 20- 598-NYN
| Pennsylvania, Rhode Island |
| Tommy O'Rourke | p | 6-2 | 200 | R | R | 2002 | Morristown,NJ | College | -- | 2021-2021 | -- | Stanford |
| Christian Peluso | c | 5-10 | 179 | R | R | 2003 | Bridgewater,NJ | -- | -- | -- | -- | Wagner |
| Travis Perry | p | 6-4 | 190 | R | R | 1997-03-08 | Morristown,NJ | AA | -- | 2018-2022 | 2018- 28- 826-SFN
| Indian River CC |
| Jake Porcello | p | 6-2 | 195 | R | R | 1991-04-02 | Morristown,NJ | College | -- | 2010-2012 | 2009- 48-1440-DET
| Seton Hall |
| Rick Porcello | p | 6-5 | 205 | R | R | 1988-12-27 | Morristown,NJ | MLB | 2009-2020 | 2008-2020 | 2007- 1- 27-DET
| -- |
| Nick Rizzo | 1b | 6-2 | 200 | L | R | 1991 | Bloomfield,NJ | College | -- | 2010-2010 | -- | Fairfield |
| Marteese Robinson | 1b | 6-1 | 180 | R | R | 1966-04-17 | West Orange,NJ | AA | -- | 1985-1990 | 1987- 6- 147-OAK
| Seton Hall |
| Nate Roe | p | 6-2 | 210 | R | R | 1989-11-13 | Plainfield,NJ | Indy | -- | 2010-2021 | -- | Rutgers, County College of Morris |
| Tyler Sanfillippo | if | 5-10 | 190 | R | R | 1997-01-11 | Wayne,NJ | College | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | Wagner, County College of Morris |
| Mike Sgaramella | p | 6-0 | 179 | R | L | 1995-09-18 | Florham Park,NJ | College | -- | 2015-2018 | -- | Villanova |
| Brendan Shamieh | p | 6-4 | 210 | R | R | 1998-05-14 | Whippany,NJ | College | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | Manhattan College, Rochester |
| Bobby Sheppard | if | 6-1 | 165 | R | R | 2000-05-25 | Basking Ridge,NJ | College | -- | 2019-2021 | -- | Seton Hall |
| Michael Sheppard | p | 5-11 | 174 | R | R | 1993-12-02 | Florham Park,NJ | College | -- | 2013-2016 | 2012- 35-1072-CIN
| ' > St. John's |
| Stephen Silvestri | p | 6-0 | 185 | L | L | 1993 | Livingston,NJ | College | -- | 2012-2015 | -- | Pennsylvania |
| Frank Spano | p | 6-4 | 220 | L | L | 2000-03-14 | Bloomingdale,NJ | College | -- | 2019-2019 | -- | Holy Cross |
| Joe Spano | p | 5-11 | 165 | L | L | 1989-10-27 | Verona,NJ | A- | -- | 2009-2013 | 2012- UDFA-TOR
| Notre Dame |
| kevin Spano | c | 5-10 | 165 | R | R | -- | Orange,NJ | College | -- | 2010-2010 | -- | Quinnipiac |
| Patrick Toohers | p | 6-6 | 230 | L | R | 1993 | Florham Park,NJ | College | -- | 2012-2016 | -- | James Madison |
| Ryan Toohers | 1b | 6-4 | 211 | L | R | 1998-07-19 | Florham Park,NJ | College | -- | 2017-2021 | -- | Villanova |
| Anthony Valvano | 2b | 5-8 | 185 | R | R | 1982-07-28 | Lyndhurst,NJ | College | -- | 2001-2004 | -- | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Jamil Vanheyningen | p | 6-6 | 235 | R | R | 1998-11-20 | West Orange,NJ | College | -- | 2018-2021 | -- | Campbell, Florence-Darlington Tech, Palm Beach Atlantic |
| Jermaine Vanheyningen | p | 6-6 | 220 | R | R | 1998-11-20 | West Orange,NJ | College | -- | 2019-2021 | -- | Campbell, Florence-Darlington Tech, Florida Intl |
| Mark Venice | 1b-of | 6-1 | 205 | L | L | 1996 | Bayonne,NJ | College | -- | 2015-2018 | -- | ' > St. John's |
| Henry Warner | p | 6-4 | 200 | R | R | 1989-10-30 | Gladstone,NJ | College | -- | 2009-2012 | -- | Seton Hall |
| Jack Zyska | of | 5-11 | 180 | R | R | 1999-08-27 | Berkeley Heights,NJ | College | -- | 2019-2021 | -- | Notre Dame |
| 98 record(s) |
