| 2020 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | - | 0 | 0 | 0 | | -- | 0 | 0 | 0 | | | 0 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | no info |
| 2019 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 76 | 40 | 36 | .526 | 3.5 | 308 | 291 | 17 | David Adams | | 66,520 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2018 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 73 | 37 | 36 | .507 | 7.0 | 253 | 238 | 15 | Lino Diaz | | 72,894 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2017 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 46 | 29 | .613 | -- | 273 | 232 | 41 | Julio Mosquera | | 71,401 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 2016 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 44 | 31 | .587 | 3.5 | 312 | 268 | 44 | Dave Bialas | | 85,513 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 2015 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 41 | 34 | .547 | -- | 344 | 292 | 52 | Pat Osborn | | 119,195 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Lost in Finals |
| 2014 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 37 | 38 | .493 | 8.5 | 314 | 327 | -13 | Mario Garza | | 122,442 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2013 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 34 | 41 | .453 | 7.5 | 295 | 305 | -10 | Justin Pope | | 128,441 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2012 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 30 | 45 | .400 | 21.5 | 317 | 384 | -67 | Justin Pope | | 141,163 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2011 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 73 | 45 | 28 | .616 | -- | 350 | 307 | 43 | Tom Slater | | 192,568 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | League Champions |
| 2010 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 74 | 34 | 40 | .459 | 16.5 | 290 | 340 | -50 | Josh Paul | | 209,018 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2009 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 76 | 47 | 29 | .618 | -- | 332 | 265 | 67 | Josh Paul | | 206,635 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | League Champions |
| 2008 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 49 | 26 | .653 | -- | 380 | 275 | 105 | Pat McMahon | | 189,876 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 2007 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 75 | 47 | 28 | .627 | 2.5 | 372 | 305 | 67 | Mike Gillespie | | 158,615 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 2006 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 74 | 45 | 29 | .608 | -- | 365 | 277 | 88 | Gaylen Pitts | | 115,395 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | League Champions |
| 2005 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 76 | 52 | 24 | .684 | -- | 373 | 258 | 115 | Andy Stankiewicz | | 155,541 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | League Champions |
| 2004 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 72 | 28 | 44 | .389 | 14.0 | 313 | 338 | -25 | Tommy John | | 147,572 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2003 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 72 | 29 | 43 | .403 | 16.5 | 281 | 327 | -46 | Andy Stankiewicz | | 163,432 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | dnq |
| 2002 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 74 | 48 | 26 | .649 | -- | 322 | 240 | 82 | Derek Shelton | | 181,936 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | League Champions |
| 2001 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | Stedler | 76 | 48 | 28 | .632 | 4.0 | 383 | 284 | 99 | David Jorn | | 188,127 | 0 | Richmond County Bank Ballpark | Lost in Semi-Finals (Brooklyn) |
| 2000 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | Stedler | 74 | 46 | 28 | .622 | 0.5 | 375 | 258 | 117 | Joe Arnold | | 102,697 | 0 | College of Staten Island Baseball Complex | League Champions |
| 1999 | Staten Island Yankees | NYPL | McNamara | 74 | 39 | 35 | .527 | 2.0 | 372 | 333 | 39 | Joe Arnold | | 117,765 | 0 | College of Staten Island Baseball Complex | dnq |
| 22 record(s) |