| Joe Abramson | P | --- | | | Canisius College |
| Armando Abreu | P | AA | | 1977-1980 | Upsala College |
| Adrean Acevedo | OF-P | Indy | | 1998-2002 | Miami Dade, NC State |
| Winter Adames | --- | Indy | | 2003-2003 | --- |
| Pedro Adorno | P | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | Saint Peter's |
| Pete Alborano | OF | AA | | 1986-1992 | Brooklyn College |
| Julius Alfonzo | 2B | Rk | | 1992-1992 | Kingsborough CC |
| Charles Aliano | SCOUT | --- | | | Adelphi |
| Christian Allegretti | P | NCAA | | 2018-2021 | Bryant University, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| Isaac Alleyne | P | AA | | 1987-1990 | --- |
| Steve Alonso | 3B-SS | --- | | | Miami Dade |
| Andre Alvarado | IF | Indy | | 2007-2010 | Iowa Wesleyan, Connors State College |
| Mike Anarumo | P | NCAA | | 2008-2012 | Le Moyne |
| Omar Andujar | C | Rk | | 2012-2012 | --- |
| Louis Anemone | 2B | --- | | | St. Francis (NY) |
| Bill Antonello | OF | MLB | 1953-1953 | 1953-1953 | --- |
| Nicholas Arcabascio | IF | NCAA | | 2014-2016 | Quinnipiac, Mercy College |
| Omar Artsen | IF | Indy | | 2014-2021 | Advanced Software Analysis, Missouri Baptist |
| Alan Ashkinazy | 2B | A+ | | 1984-1986 | New York Tech |
| Bob Aspromonte | 3B | MLB | 1956-1971 | 1956-1971 | --- |
| Ken Aspromonte | 2B | MLB | 1957-1963 | 1957-1963 | --- |
| Rich Aurilia | SS | MLB | 1995-2009 | 1990-2009 | St. John's |
| Channing Austin | P | NCAA | | 2021-2021 | Virginia, USC |
| Kevin Baez | SS | MLB | 1990-1993 | 1988-2005 | Dominican College |
| Brian Baker | P | AAA | | 2002-2015 | Columbus State |
| Daniel Bakst | 3B | Rk | | 2017-2019 | Stanford |
| Tony Balsamo | P | MLB | 1962-1962 | 1962-1962 | Fordham |
| Andrew Barbaro | C | Indy | | 2008-2011 | Iowa Wesleyan |
| John Barrett | OF | MLB | 1872-1872 | 1872-1872 | --- |
| Chris Basso | C | NCAA | | 1990-1990 | Miami Dade, Indian River CC, Jacksonville |
| Emil Batch | 3B-OF | MLB | 1904-1907 | 1904-1907 | --- |
| Larry Battam | 3B | MLB | 1895-1895 | 1895-1895 | --- |
| Alex Bautista | OF | AAA | | 2014-2016 | Lindsey Wilson College, Clarendon College |
| Hank Behrman | P | MLB | 1946-1949 | 1946-1949 | --- |
| Nelson Bellido | P | --- | | | --- |
| Ludwig Benedetti | SS | --- | | | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Thomas Bennett | C-1B | NCAA | | 2002-2005 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Carlos Benoit | P | NCAA | | 2017-2019 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff, Lackawanna College |
| Sam Berg | SS-P | NCAA | | 2009-2012 | Northeastern |
| Jason Berrios | OF | Indy | | 2013-2013 | Concordia College, Dominican College |
| Dellin Betances | P | MLB | 2011-2021 | 2006-2021 | --- |
| Kraig Binick | OF | AAA | | 2004-2013 | New York Tech |
| George Blaum | 1B | --- | | | --- |
| Curt Blefary | OF-1B | MLB | 1965-1972 | 1965-1972 | Towson, Wagner |
| Ned Bligh | C | MLB | 1886-1890 | 1886-1890 | --- |
| Billy Blitzer | SCOUT | --- | | | Hunter College |
| Cy Block | 3B | MLB | 1942-1946 | 1942-1946 | --- |
| Clint Blume | P | MLB | 1922-1923 | 1922-1923 | Colgate |
| Anthony Bocchino | OF | A+ | | 1999-2005 | Marist |
| Keith Bodie | OF | AAA | | 1977-1985 | --- |
| Adam Bogosian | P | NCAA | | 2021-2021 | Lafayette College |
| Eddie Booth | OF | MLB | 1872-1876 | 1872-1876 | --- |
| Sebby Borriello | C | A | | 1981-1982 | St. John's |
| Michael Bourbakis | P | A | | 1995-1998 | --- |
| AJ Brack | P | Indy | | 1999-2004 | Rollins |
| Ken Brett | P | MLB | 1967-1981 | 1967-1981 | --- |
| Jim Britt | P | MLB | 1872-1873 | 1872-1873 | --- |
| Robert Britt | OF | A+ | | 1987-1988 | Wilmington University |
| Frank Brooks | P | MLB | 2004-2005 | 1999-2008 | Florida State |
| Oliver Brown | OF | MLB | 1872-1875 | 1872-1875 | --- |
| Tommy Brown | SS-OF | MLB | 1944-1953 | 1944-1953 | --- |
| Jason Bryan | OF | A+ | | 1999-2008 | --- |
| Jim Buccheri | OF | AAA | | 1988-2000 | Golden West College |
| Josh Bunce | OF | MLB | 1877-1877 | 1877-1877 | --- |
| Jack Burdock | 2B | MLB | 1872-1891 | 1872-1891 | --- |
| Joe Burke | C | A+ | | 2004-2011 | St. John's |
| Pat Burns | 1B | MLB | 1884-1884 | 1884-1884 | --- |
| Edward Burzo | OF | --- | | | Nassau CC |
| Dick Butler | C | MLB | 1897-1899 | 1897-1899 | --- |
| David Caldwell | P | A+ | | 1994-2004 | Northeast Texas CC |
| Mike Campagno | P | Indy | | 1994-1994 | Coastal Carolina |
| Sal Campisi | P | MLB | 1969-1971 | 1969-1971 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Sal Candela | IF | NCAA | | 2001-2004 | Manhattan College |
| John Candelaria | P | MLB | 1975-1993 | 1975-1993 | --- |
| John Cangelosi | OF | MLB | 1985-1999 | 1982-1999 | Miami Dade |
| Gary Caraballo | 3B | AA | | 1989-2002 | --- |
| Sean Carberry | 2B-SS | NCAA | | 2008-2008 | Villanova |
| Nick Cardieri | C | NCAA | | 2018-2021 | Stetson |
| Conrad Cardinal | P | MLB | 1963-1963 | 1963-1963 | --- |
| Antonio Cardona | P | NCAA | | 2005-2006 | Stony Brook, Cornell |
| Paco Cardona | 2B | A- | | 1995-2001 | Belhaven College |
| William Cardona | SS | NCAA | | 2009-2012 | Siena College |
| Tom Carey | SS | MLB | 1871-1879 | 1871-1879 | --- |
| Steven Carp | P | NCAA | | 1971-1974 | Georgia |
| Frank Carpin | P | MLB | 1965-1966 | 1965-1966 | Notre Dame |
| Jorge Carrion | P | A | | 1996-1998 | --- |
| Yusuf Carter | C | AA | | 2005-2014 | El Paso CC |
| Jerry Casale | P | MLB | 1958-1962 | 1958-1962 | --- |
| Richard Case | P | --- | | | --- |
| Michael Cassavella | P | JrCollege | | 2013-2014 | New York Tech, Kingsborough CC |
| John Cassidy | OF | MLB | 1875-1885 | 1875-1885 | --- |
| Anthony Castellano | OF | Indy | | 2013-2013 | Marywood |
| Mike Castellano | 3B | Indy | | 2010-2013 | Marywood |
| John Castiglione | C | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | Wagner |
| Vladimir Ceverino | P | --- | | | St. John's |
| Jack Chapman | OF | MLB | 1874-1876 | 1874-1876 | --- |
| Mike Chartak | OF | MLB | 1940-1944 | 1940-1944 | --- |
| Jim Chatterton | OF-1B | MLB | 1884-1884 | 1884-1884 | --- |
| Will Cheatham | 1B | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | Akron, CCBC Essex |
| Roshawn Cherry | P | NCAA | | 2002-2004 | Norfolk State |
| Joel Chimelis | SS | AAA | | 1988-2002 | Texas, Howard College |
| Bob Chipman | P | MLB | 1941-1952 | 1941-1952 | --- |
| Mike Chiusano | C | Rk | | 1988-1989 | --- |
| Danny Christensen | P | AA | | 2002-2009 | --- |
| Keith Christensen | P | NCAA | | 2007-2009 | Louisiana-Monroe, Gulf Coast CC |
| Larry Ciaffone | OF | MLB | 1951-1951 | 1951-1951 | --- |
| Denny Clare | 2B | MLB | 1872-1872 | 1872-1872 | --- |
| Jim Clark | OF | MLB | 1911-1912 | 1911-1912 | Bucknell |
| Spider Clark | OF | MLB | 1889-1890 | 1889-1890 | --- |
| Hy Cohen | P | MLB | 1955-1955 | 1955-1955 | --- |
| Glenn Coleman | OF | Rk | | 1991-1991 | College of the Desert |
| Chris Coletta | OF | MLB | 1972-1972 | 1972-1976 | --- |
| Zip Collins | OF | MLB | 1914-1921 | 1914-1921 | --- |
| Richard Collyer | P | A+ | | 1979-1981 | --- |
| Paul Colontino | OF | Rk | | 1987-1988 | --- |
| Jeff Columbano | C-1B | Rk | | 1990-1990 | St. Francis (NY) |
| Terence Connelly | IF | A | | 2013-2018 | UNC Wilmington |
| Ed Connolly | C | MLB | 1929-1932 | 1929-1932 | --- |
| Ed Connolly | P | MLB | 1964-1967 | 1964-1967 | Massachusetts |
| Matt Connolly | OF | Indy | | 1998-2006 | --- |
| Shamus Connolly | IF | NCAA | | 2019-2019 | Wagner |
| Mark Connor | P | --- | | | Manhattan College, Belmont Abbey College |
| Chuck Connors | 1B | MLB | 1949-1951 | 1949-1951 | Seton Hall |
| Donald Cook | P | --- | | | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Larry Corcoran | P | MLB | 1880-1887 | 1880-1887 | --- |
| Mike Corcoran | P | MLB | 1884-1884 | 1884-1884 | --- |
| Daniel Corona | SS | --- | | | Wake Forest |
| Dalphie Correa | SS | Rk | | 1992-2006 | --- |
| Bob Costello | C | A | | 1981-1983 | New York Tech |
| Dennis Crowley | SS-2B | A+ | | 1989-1989 | Palm Beach Atlantic, College of Staten Island, John Jay |
| Chris Cruz | IF-OF | NCAA | | 2006-2007 | Stony Brook |
| Julio Cruz | 2B | MLB | 1977-1986 | 1976-1988 | San Bernardino Valley |
| Alex Cuas | P | NCAA | | 2015-2018 | Towson, Hagerstown CC |
| Jose Cuas | P | AAA | | 2013-2021 | Maryland |
| Charles D'Elia | IF | NCAA | | 2000-2003 | Quinnipiac |
| John Dailey | SS | MLB | 1875-1875 | 1875-1875 | --- |
| Jimmy Daley | P | Indy | | 2013-2016 | Kingsborough CC |
| Dorian Daughtry | OF | A+ | | 1987-1989 | Kingsborough CC, Miami Dade |
| Tommy Davis | OF | MLB | 1959-1976 | 1957-1976 | --- |
| Angel De La Cruz | 1B | NCAA | | 2021-2021 | UTRGV |
| Artie Dede | C | MLB | 1916-1916 | 1916-1916 | --- |
| Herman Dehlman | 1B | MLB | 1872-1877 | 1872-1877 | --- |
| David DeJesus | CF | MLB | 2003-2015 | 1998-2015 | Rutgers |
| Jose DeJesus | P | MLB | 1988-1994 | 1985-1999 | --- |
| Bill DeKoning | C | MLB | 1945-1945 | 1945-1945 | Boston College |
| Anderson DeLeon | P | Rk | | 2016-2021 | Iowa Central CC |
| Billy DeMars | SS | MLB | 1948-1951 | 1948-1951 | --- |
| Nick Desalvo | P | NCAA | | 2018-2020 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Jim Desapio | P | A- | | 1988-1989 | St. Francis (NY) |
| John Desiderio | 2B | NCAA | | 2002-2005 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Daniel DeSouza | OF | Rk | | 2004-2005 | Connors State College |
| Frank Devin | OF | MLB | 1883-1886 | 1883-1886 | --- |
| Alex Diaz | CF-RF | MLB | 1992-1999 | 1987-2003 | --- |
| Eli Diaz | P | Rk | | 2006-2007 | --- |
| Jorge Diaz | P | Rk | | 2011-2013 | --- |
| Joseph DiBenedetto | P | --- | | | --- |
| Nick Dileo | P | NCAA | | 2014-2016 | Wagner |
| Lou DiMuro | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Andrew DiOrio | 3B-SS | Indy | | 1995-2002 | Wagner |
| Benny Distefano | 1B-OF | MLB | 1984-1992 | 1982-1993 | Alvin CC |
| Mike Donovan | 3B | MLB | 1904-1908 | 1904-1908 | --- |
| Gregory Dorfman | P | NCAA | | 2020-2020 | Delaware State |
| Dustin Downs | IF | NCAA | | 2000-2003 | Villanova, Borough of Manhattan CC, Manhattan College |
| Ed Dugan | P | MLB | 1884-1884 | 1884-1884 | --- |
| Brian Dunne | P | Rk | | 1995-1996 | Newman |
| Shawon Dunston | SS | MLB | 1985-2002 | 1982-2002 | --- |
| Roberto Duran | 3B | A- | | 2010-2013 | Miami Dade |
| Dave Eggler | OF | MLB | 1871-1885 | 1871-1885 | --- |
| Hack Eibel | OF-P | MLB | 1912-1920 | 1912-1920 | --- |
| Mitchell Eilenberg | P | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | Massachusetts |
| Harry Eisenstat | P | MLB | 1935-1942 | 1935-1942 | --- |
| Chris Elder | OF | A+ | | 2009-2015 | Oral Roberts, Sacramento City College |
| Jarrett England | IF | NCAA | | 2003-2003 | Middle Tenn State, Columbia State CC |
| Johnny Enzmann | P | MLB | 1914-1920 | 1914-1920 | --- |
| Jim Eschen | OF | MLB | 1915-1915 | 1915-1915 | --- |
| Luis Espiritu | SS | A+ | | 2015-2016 | --- |
| Justin Esposito | P | NCAA | | 2006-2008 | Monmouth, Brookdale CC |
| Danny Etkin | C | Indy | | 2005-2009 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Hassan Evans | OF | Indy | | 2013-2016 | Herkimer County CC, Delaware State |
| Jason Faigin | P | A | | 1999-2004 | Rowan, Brookdale CC |
| Joey Falcone | OF | A+ | | 2011-2015 | Columbia, College of Staten Island |
| Pete Falcone | P | MLB | 1975-1984 | 1975-1989 | Kingsborough CC |
| John Fantauzzi | 1B | A+ | | 1990-1996 | Florida Intl, Maryland |
| Joe Farrell | 3B | MLB | 1882-1886 | 1882-1886 | --- |
| Ruben Feliciano | P | A | | 2000-2001 | Kingsborough CC, Cochise College |
| Harry Felix | P | MLB | 1901-1902 | 1901-1902 | --- |
| Craig Fellows | P | --- | | | --- |
| Bob Ferguson | 3B | MLB | 1871-1884 | 1871-1884 | --- |
| Mike Fermaint | 2B | A+ | | 1990-1991 | Kingsborough CC |
| Joseph Fernando | 3B-2B | Rk | | 2016-2021 | Bethune-Cookman, NE Oklahoma AM |
| Al Ferrara | OF | MLB | 1963-1971 | 1963-1971 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Nelson Figueroa | P | MLB | 2000-2011 | 1995-2013 | Brandeis |
| Neal Finn | 2B-3B | MLB | 1930-1933 | 1930-1933 | --- |
| Mike Fiore | 1B | MLB | 1968-1972 | 1968-1978 | --- |
| Vincent Fiore | P | NCAA | | 2010-2011 | Hartford, Monroe CC |
| John Fitzgerald | P | MLB | 1958-1958 | 1958-1958 | --- |
| Luis Flores | C | --- | | | Gardner-Webb |
| Cornell Foggie | OF | A- | | 1989-1989 | George Washington |
| Roger Foltynowicz | 3B | Rk | | 1999-1999 | --- |
| Julio Fortuna | P | --- | | | --- |
| John Franco | P | MLB | 1984-2005 | 1979-2005 | St. John's |
| Joe Franzese | IF | NCAA | | 2005-2006 | Manhattan College, Bloomfield College |
| Nunzio Franzese | IF-OF | NCAA | | 2005-2007 | Manhattan College |
| Skye Freeman | P | NCAA | | 2011-2014 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Keith Frerichs | P | NCAA | | 2001-2004 | Lehigh |
| Chad Frontera | P | AAA | | 1992-1998 | Seton Hall |
| Joe Fuccillo | P | Rk | | 1993-1993 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Henry Fuentes | OF | Indy | | 2009-2011 | Dowling College |
| Tom Fusco | P | A | | 1990-1992 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Chris Garcia | P | --- | | | --- |
| Chris Garcia | 1B | A+ | | 2007-2012 | St. Petersburg College |
| Danny Garcia | OF-1B | MLB | 1981-1981 | 1977-1982 | Baruch College |
| Edwin Garcia | 3B | NCAA | | 2003-2003 | Norfolk State |
| Jumpy Garcia | C | NCAA | | 2011-2011 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi, Southeastern CC, Connors State College |
| Dion Gargagriano | P | Rk | | 1990-1991 | County College of Morris |
| Sean Gargin | P | A- | | 1987-1987 | John Jay |
| Philip Gerena | UT | NCAA | | 2020-2020 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Joe Giacomiazzio | PH | Indy | | 2005-2005 | Montclair State |
| Bob Giallombardo | P | MLB | 1958-1958 | 1958-1958 | --- |
| Ray Giannelli | 3B | MLB | 1991-1995 | 1988-1997 | New York Tech |
| Charlie Girard | P | MLB | 1910-1910 | 1910-1910 | --- |
| Andrew Gitto | IF | NCAA | | 2005-2005 | Saint Peter's |
| Gaetano Giunta | IF | Indy | | 2012-2013 | Bridgeport |
| Keith Glauber | P | MLB | 1998-2000 | 1994-2001 | Montclair State, Coastal Carolina |
| Ross Gload | 1B | MLB | 2000-2011 | 1997-2011 | South Florida |
| Ed Goebel | OF | MLB | 1922-1922 | 1922-1922 | Pennsylvania |
| Norris Gordon | IF | NCAA | | 2002-2005 | Delaware State |
| Sid Gordon | OF-3B | MLB | 1941-1955 | 1941-1955 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Braulio Goris | OF-1B | A- | | 1995-1997 | --- |
| Khalil Gourdin | OF | Indy | | 2001-2001 | New York Tech |
| Chris Grabowski | OF | NCAA | | 2004-2005 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Kasceim Graham | P | NCAA | | 2010-2013 | SUNY - Albany |
| Jalen Grant | P | --- | | | George Mason, Manhattanville |
| Steve Grilli | P | MLB | 1975-1979 | 1975-1981 | Gannon |
| Ken Grzelaczyk | P | A+ | | 1992-1994 | St. John's |
| Carlos Guzman | RF | AAA | | 2007-2017 | Brookdale CC |
| Anthony Hajjar | 1B-3B | NCAA | | 2010-2013 | Fairfield |
| John Halama | P | MLB | 1998-2006 | 1994-2012 | St. Francis (IL) |
| Patrick Hannaway | P | Rk | | 2000-2001 | Duke |
| Gerard Haran | C-1B | Rk | | 2007-2010 | The College of New Jersey |
| James Harris | P | --- | | | Mississippi State |
| Rainford Harris | OF | Rk | | 1986-1986 | Central State |
| Ted Hart | 1B | NCAA | | 2001-2002 | Navy |
| Sam Hasty | P | NCAA | | 2010-2013 | Rutgers |
| Paris Hayden | OF | AA | | 1987-1991 | Indian River CC |
| Dom Hayes | OF | NCAA | | 2008-2010 | New Jersey Tech, West Virginia |
| Jackie Hayes | C-OF | MLB | 1882-1890 | 1882-1890 | --- |
| Tom Hayes | 3B-SS | AAA | | 1980-1985 | Texas Wesleyan |
| Bunny Hearn | P | MLB | 1926-1929 | 1926-1929 | --- |
| Jake Hehl | P | MLB | 1918-1918 | 1918-1918 | --- |
| Al Heist | OF | MLB | 1960-1962 | 1960-1962 | --- |
| Kevin Heller | OF | AA | | 2012-2015 | Amherst College |
| Bruce Henderson | 1B | --- | | | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Mark Henry | P | Indy | | 1997-2003 | --- |
| David Hernandez | P | NCAA | | 2015-2018 | Queens College. |
| Gabriel Hernandez | IF | NCAA | | 2013-2016 | Boston College |
| Johnny Hernandez | OF | A+ | | 1999-2010 | --- |
| Marcus Hernandez | C | NCAA | | 2012-2013 | Bucknell |
| Michael Hernandez | OF | AA | | 2005-2014 | Oklahoma State, Connors State College, Daytona Beach CC |
| Tom Hess | C | MLB | 1892-1892 | 1892-1892 | --- |
| Anthony Hewitt | OF | AA | | 2008-2016 | --- |
| George Hewitt | IF | NCAA | | 2017-2017 | Michigan |
| Mark Hindy | P | Rk | | 1994-1995 | Vanderbilt |
| Curtis Hires | C | --- | | | --- |
| Tommy Holmes | OF | MLB | 1942-1952 | 1942-1952 | --- |
| Jonathan Holzer | OF | NCAA | | 2001-2004 | Manhattan College |
| Mike Hoosier | OF | NCAA | | 2007-2010 | Navy |
| Sam Hope | P | MLB | 1907-1907 | 1907-1907 | --- |
| Ed Horowitz | C | AA | | 1987-1992 | Rider |
| Les Howe | P | MLB | 1923-1924 | 1923-1924 | --- |
| Waite Hoyt | P | MLB | 1918-1938 | 1918-1938 | --- |
| Mark Imbo | P | NCAA | | 2005-2008 | Saint Joseph's |
| Fred Jacklitsch | C | MLB | 1900-1910 | 1900-1910 | --- |
| John Jasilli | IF-P | NCAA | | 2000-2002 | Quinnipiac |
| Bernie Jenkins | OF | AA | | 1988-1995 | St. Francis (NY) |
| Williams Jerez | P | MLB | 2018-2019 | 2011-2021 | --- |
| Pedro Jimenez | P | NCAA | | 2003-2004 | Long Island-Brooklyn, NC Wesleyan |
| James Jones | P | MLB | 2014-2015 | 2007-2021 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Michael Jordan | OF | AA | | 1994-1994 | North Carolina |
| Brandon Joseph | IF | --- | | | --- |
| Joe Judge | 1B | MLB | 1915-1934 | 1915-1934 | --- |
| Eric Kalman | IF | NCAA | | 2013-2017 | George Washington, Lincoln Memorial |
| Justin Kaplan | P | --- | | | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Ian Karlsson | P | NCAA | | 2008-2010 | Wagner |
| Herb Karpel | P | MLB | 1946-1946 | 1946-1946 | --- |
| Willie Keeler | OF | MLB | 1892-1910 | 1892-1910 | --- |
| Red Kellett | SS-2B | MLB | 1934-1934 | 1934-1934 | --- |
| Chris Kelly | P | Indy | | 2003-2003 | College of Staten Island |
| Doc Kennedy | C | MLB | 1879-1883 | 1879-1883 | --- |
| John Kenney | OF | MLB | 1872-1872 | 1872-1872 | --- |
| Caleb Kerbs | IF | NCAA | | 2016-2019 | Maine |
| Henry Kessler | SS-OF | MLB | 1873-1877 | 1873-1877 | --- |
| Evans Killeen | P | MLB | 1959-1959 | 1959-1959 | --- |
| Cole Kimball | P | MLB | 2011-2011 | 2004-2015 | Centenary College, St. John's |
| Willie King | 1B | A | | 1996-2005 | --- |
| Duane Kinnon | 1B | A- | | 1993-1993 | Boston College |
| Chris Klein | OF-3B | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | West Virginia |
| Jake Knowdell | C | MLB | 1874-1878 | 1874-1878 | --- |
| Jim Korwan | P | MLB | 1894-1897 | 1894-1897 | --- |
| Sandy Koufax | P | MLB | 1955-1966 | 1955-1966 | Cincinnati |
| Al Labozzetta | P | AA | | 1984-1987 | New York Tech |
| Anthony Lafauci | P | NCAA | | 2010-2013 | Iona College |
| Joe Lake | P | MLB | 1908-1913 | 1908-1913 | --- |
| Charles Lalane | 2B-SS | NCAA | | 2004-2007 | Norfolk State |
| Robert Lamber | P | --- | | | New York Tech |
| Julio LaSalle | P | A | | 2002-2004 | Palm Beach State |
| Bob Lawrence | P | MLB | 1924-1924 | 1924-1924 | --- |
| Christian Layne | OF | NCAA | | 2018-2021 | Central Ct State |
| Evan Layne | P | NCAA | | 2016-2019 | Fairleigh Dickinson, Lake Erie College |
| Richie Lazar | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Francis Leahy | P | NCAA | | 2003-2003 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Mike Ledwith | C | MLB | 1874-1874 | 1874-1874 | --- |
| Steve Lembo | C | MLB | 1950-1952 | 1950-1952 | --- |
| Chris Lemonis | 2B-SS | AAA | | 1995-2004 | The Citadel |
| Bill Lennon | C | MLB | 1871-1873 | 1871-1873 | --- |
| Bob Lennon | OF | MLB | 1954-1957 | 1954-1957 | --- |
| Conan Leon | P-IF | NCAA | | 2011-2013 | Iona College |
| Nathaniel Leon | P | NCAA | | 2013-2016 | Saint Peter's |
| Dennis Leonard | P | MLB | 1974-1986 | 1974-1986 | Iona College |
| Denzel Leslie | OF-P | NCAA | | 2010-2010 | Delaware State |
| Dwayne Lewis | 2B | A | | 1994-1996 | Tarleton State |
| Eugene Lightfoot | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Rodney Linares | IF | Rk | | 1997-1998 | --- |
| Dallas Lind | P | --- | | | Richmond |
| Joe Linsalata | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Angelo Lipetri | P | MLB | 1956-1958 | 1956-1958 | --- |
| Paul LoDuca | C | MLB | 1998-2008 | 1993-2010 | Arizona State, Glendale CC AZ |
| Bill Lohrman | P | MLB | 1934-1944 | 1934-1944 | --- |
| Fausto Lopez | IF | NCAA | | 2018-2021 | Troy, Pensacola State, Middle Tenn State |
| Luis Lopez | 3B-1B | MLB | 2001-2004 | 1991-2014 | Coastal Carolina |
| Luis Lopez | C-1B | MLB | 1990-1991 | 1984-2004 | --- |
| Luca Lotito | IF | NCAA | | 2019-2021 | Pittsburgh, Iona College |
| Curtis Lovelle | P | NCAA | | 2005-2005 | Delaware State |
| Turk Lown | P | MLB | 1951-1962 | 1951-1962 | --- |
| Angel Lugo | SS | A+ | | 1988-1991 | --- |
| Ed Lynch | P | MLB | 1980-1987 | 1974-1988 | South Carolina |
| Waddy MacPhee | 3B | MLB | 1922-1922 | 1922-1922 | Princeton |
| Matthew Maffei | 1B | --- | | | Ferrum College |
| Robbie Maguire | P | NCAA | | 2011-2015 | Sacred Heart |
| Charlie Malay | 2B-OF | MLB | 1905-1905 | 1905-1905 | --- |
| Joe Malay | 1B | MLB | 1933-1935 | 1933-1935 | --- |
| Alexis Maldonado | 2B | A | | 2010-2016 | Holy Cross |
| Brian Manning | OF | AA | | 1996-1999 | Allegheny College |
| Christopher Manno | P | AA | | 2007-2014 | Duke |
| Mike Marchiano | OF | A+ | | 1997-2000 | Fordham |
| Chris Marino | P | NCAA | | 2005-2008 | Wagner |
| Alan Marr | 3B | A+ | | 1980-1984 | Lamar |
| Ariel Martin | 1B | Rk | | 1993-1996 | Cal State Dominguez Hills |
| Pat Martin | P | MLB | 1919-1920 | 1919-1920 | --- |
| Austen Martinez | P | NCAA | | 2018-2021 | Marshall, Gateway CC, St. Thomas Aquinas |
| Dave Martinez | OF | MLB | 1986-2001 | 1983-2001 | Valencia CC |
| Kevin Martir | C | A- | | 2013-2018 | Maryland |
| John Massoni | P-OF | NCAA | | 2006-2006 | Long Island-Brooklyn, John Jay |
| Musa Matiwane | P | NCAA | | 2016-2019 | Delaware State, Oberlin College |
| Ralph Mauriello | P | MLB | 1958-1958 | 1958-1958 | --- |
| Tom McAvoy | P | MLB | 1959-1959 | 1959-1959 | --- |
| Jerry McCarthy | 1B | MLB | 1948-1948 | 1948-1948 | --- |
| Oliver McCarthy | P | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | Duke |
| J.T. McEwan | 2B | --- | | | Saint Peter's |
| Sean McFadden | OF | NCAA | | 2008-2010 | Saint Peter's |
| Terry McFarlin | P | AAA | | 1991-1995 | --- |
| John McGlone | 3B | MLB | 1886-1888 | 1886-1888 | --- |
| Don McMahon | P | MLB | 1957-1974 | 1957-1974 | --- |
| Matt McMahon | P | NCAA | | 2006-2009 | Saint Peter's |
| Brandon McMillan | P | NCAA | | 2009-2011 | Saint Peter's |
| George McQuillan | P | MLB | 1907-1918 | 1907-1918 | --- |
| George Meakim | P | MLB | 1890-1895 | 1890-1895 | --- |
| Miguel Mejia | P | AAA | | 2009-2019 | Florida Intl, Pensacola State |
| Tommy Mejia | P | A- | | 2008-2009 | Dominican College |
| Chrystian Mervilus | IF | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | Grambling State |
| CJ Mervilus | IF | NCAA | | 2019-2019 | Grambling State |
| Al Metcalfe | 3B | MLB | 1875-1875 | 1875-1875 | --- |
| George Miguel | P | A- | | 1981-1983 | --- |
| Doggie Miller | OF-C | MLB | 1884-1896 | 1884-1896 | --- |
| Ian Miller | P | NCAA | | 2015-2019 | Harvard |
| Charles Mirailh | SS | Rk | | 1994-1994 | --- |
| Jason Miranda | IF | NCAA | | 2007-2007 | Texas State, Clarendon College |
| Charles Misiano | SS-2B | NCAA | | 2014-2017 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Ali Modami | 1B | Indy | | 2002-2005 | Oklahoma State |
| Rinty Monahan | P | MLB | 1953-1953 | 1953-1953 | Niagara |
| Raymond Montanez | 2B | NCAA | | 2001-2005 | Vermont |
| Vincent Monti | P | --- | | | --- |
| Al Moore | OF | MLB | 1925-1926 | 1925-1926 | St. John's |
| Joe Morales | IF | AA | | 1981-1985 | Long Beach State, Col of Sequoias |
| Julio Morales | 1B | --- | | | Nassau CC, C.W. Post Campus/Long Island, Texas A&M |
| Larry Morello | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Bill Morgan | OF-SS | MLB | 1882-1884 | 1882-1884 | --- |
| Emerson Morillo | P | NCAA | | 2010-2013 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Dan Morogiello | P | MLB | 1983-1983 | 1977-1985 | Seton Hall |
| Dan Morris | 2B-SS | NCAA | | 2012-2012 | Villanova |
| Dan Morris | IF | NCAA | | 2014-2015 | Cornell |
| Ed Morris | P | MLB | 1884-1890 | 1884-1890 | --- |
| Bruce Morrison | 1B | A+ | | 1981-1983 | Wichita State |
| John Mortillaro | P | AA | | 1982-1984 | Jacksonville State |
| Todd Moser | P | AA | | 1998-2010 | Florida Atlantic, St Col of FL |
| Danny Murphy | C | MLB | 1892-1892 | 1892-1892 | --- |
| John Murphy | P | AAA | | 1977-1981 | --- |
| Dion Myles | OF | Rk | | 1997-1997 | --- |
| Eric Naison-Phillips | P | NCAA | | 2000-2003 | Yale |
| Larry Napp | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Jorge Navarette | P | Rk | | 2011-2011 | Monroe CC |
| Ernie Nieves | P | AA | | 1989-2001 | --- |
| Jim Norris | OF | MLB | 1977-1980 | 1968-1981 | Maryland |
| Craig Noto | COACH | --- | | | John Jay |
| Antonio Nunez | SS | AAA | | 2014-2018 | Western Oklahoma State |
| Jose Nunez | 2B | A+ | | 1996-2000 | Northeast Texas CC |
| Don O'Toole | P | --- | | | Wagner |
| Whitey Ock | C | MLB | 1935-1935 | 1935-1935 | Lehigh |
| Joe Ojeda | P | A- | | 1998-1999 | St. Francis (IL) |
| Andy Olsen | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Ed Olsen | P | NCAA | | 1997-1998 | St. John's |
| Peter Orsi | P | NCAA | | 2004-2006 | Long Island-Brooklyn, Nyack College |
| Wilberto Ortiz | 3B-SS | AAA | | 2006-2012 | Dowling College |
| Charlie Pabor | OF | MLB | 1871-1875 | 1871-1875 | --- |
| Adam Pace | P | A+ | | 2000-2002 | Dominican College |
| John Pacella | P | MLB | 1977-1986 | 1977-1988 | --- |
| Bryan Padilla | IF | --- | | | Connecticut |
| Justin Pagan | IF | NCAA | | 1999-2002 | Lehigh |
| Joshua Palacios | RF-CF | MLB | 2021-2021 | 2014-2021 | San Jacinto, Auburn |
| Rey Palacios | C-3B | MLB | 1988-1990 | 1983-1993 | Kingsborough CC |
| Richie Palacios | 2B-CF | AAA | | 2016-2021 | Towson |
| Robb Paller | OF | Indy | | 2012-2021 | Columbia |
| Michael Papa | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Tommy Papadopoulos | IF | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | St. John's, LSU-Eunice |
| Tom Park | P | NCAA | | 2001-2005 | New York Tech |
| David Parouse | C | Rk | | 1988-1988 | Dominican College |
| Dickey Pearce | SS | MLB | 1871-1877 | 1871-1877 | --- |
| Joseph Pena | SS | A | | 2018-2019 | St. Thomas Aquinas |
| Joe Pepitone | 1B-OF | MLB | 1962-1973 | 1962-1976 | --- |
| Pepper Peploski | 3B | MLB | 1913-1913 | 1913-1913 | Seton Hall |
| Allendi Peralta | IF | NCAA | | 2004-2006 | New York Tech |
| Carlos Perez | 2B | --- | | | --- |
| Chris Perez | IF | NCAA | | 2016-2017 | Grambling State |
| Miguel Perez | SS | NCAA | | 2003-2004 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Kalif Person | P | NCAA | | 2006-2006 | Coppin State College |
| Rico Petrocelli | SS-3B | MLB | 1963-1976 | 1963-1976 | --- |
| Gilberto Pichardo | OF | Rk | | 1997-1999 | --- |
| Mario Picone | P | MLB | 1947-1954 | 1947-1954 | --- |
| Michael Pierre | 2B | Indy | | 2005-2007 | Indian River CC |
| Bill Pierro | P | MLB | 1950-1950 | 1950-1950 | --- |
| Joe Pignatano | C | MLB | 1957-1962 | 1957-1962 | --- |
| Jonathan Pineiro | 2B-SS | NCAA | | 2012-2012 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Ed Pinkham | 3B | MLB | 1871-1871 | 1871-1871 | --- |
| Steve Pinto | OF-1B | Indy | | 1996-1997 | --- |
| Herman Pitz | C | MLB | 1890-1890 | 1890-1890 | --- |
| Nick Pizza | OF-IF | NCAA | | 2002-2004 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Mark Polhemus | OF | MLB | 1887-1887 | 1887-1887 | --- |
| Greg Polius | P-OF | NCAA | | 2005-2006 | Hofstra |
| Angel Polo | UT | NCAA | | 2013-2014 | Alcorn State, Monroe CC |
| John Pomorski | P | MLB | 1934-1934 | 1934-1934 | --- |
| Barry Poris | 1B-P | --- | | | City College of New York |
| Jim Prendergast | P | MLB | 1948-1948 | 1948-1948 | --- |
| Wilfred Puentes | OF | A+ | | 1977-1978 | Monmouth |
| John Puhl | 3B | MLB | 1898-1899 | 1898-1899 | --- |
| David Qualben | P | A+ | | 2004-2011 | Pace |
| Pedro Rabassa | OF | A- | | 1978-1981 | --- |
| Andy Raffa | C | --- | | | Palm Beach Atlantic |
| Peto Ramirez | OF | AA | | 1991-2003 | --- |
| Angel Ramos | OF | NCAA | | 2001-2002 | Liberty |
| Valentin Ramos | 1B | Rk | | 2006-2008 | --- |
| Tom Ravashiere | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Phil Reardon | OF | MLB | 1906-1906 | 1906-1906 | --- |
| Wilmot Reedy | 2B | Rk | | 1979-1979 | --- |
| Bugs Reisigl | P | MLB | 1911-1911 | 1911-1911 | --- |
| Jack Remsen | OF | MLB | 1872-1884 | 1872-1884 | --- |
| William Rexter | OF | MLB | 1875-1875 | 1875-1875 | --- |
| Jimmy Ring | P | MLB | 1917-1928 | 1917-1928 | --- |
| Luis Rios | OF | NCAA | | 2015-2016 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Melvin Rios | C-OF | NCAA | | 2012-2015 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| George Rivera | P | Rk | | 1977-1977 | --- |
| Raul Rivera | P | Rk | | 1997-2004 | --- |
| Phil Rizzuto | SS | MLB | 1941-1956 | 1941-1956 | --- |
| Bryan Roberts | 2B | NCAA | | 2007-2008 | Northeastern, Binghamton |
| Chris Rodriguez | IF | NCAA | | 2017-2019 | USC-Upstate |
| Francisco Rodriguez | P | Rk | | 2013-2016 | --- |
| Frankie Rodriguez | P | MLB | 1995-2001 | 1991-2008 | Howard College |
| Manny Rodriguez | SS | AA | | 2015-2021 | Cincinnati |
| Richard Rodriguez | IF | NCAA | | 2014-2014 | Delaware State, Cincinnati |
| Yonis Rodriguez | P | A+ | | 1980-1985 | --- |
| Sean Rogan | P | Rk | | 1995-1995 | Westminster College |
| Fraley Rogers | OF | MLB | 1872-1873 | 1872-1873 | --- |
| Saul Rogovin | P | MLB | 1949-1957 | 1949-1957 | --- |
| Freddy Rojas | UT | NCAA | | 2018-2021 | UTRGV, Monroe CC, Hillsborough CC |
| Randy Rojas | IF | A | | 2001-2003 | Connors State College |
| Junior Roman | OF | AA | | 1977-1979 | --- |
| Jim Romano | P | MLB | 1950-1950 | 1950-1950 | --- |
| Joe Romano | P-1B | NCAA | | 2006-2008 | St. Francis (NY), Saint Peter's |
| Joe Romero | P | NCAA | | 2014-2017 | SUNY - Albany |
| David Rosario | P | AAA | | 1986-2001 | --- |
| Chief Roseman | OF | MLB | 1882-1890 | 1882-1890 | --- |
| Steve Rosenberg | P | MLB | 1988-1991 | 1985-1993 | Florida, Broward College |
| Wayne Rosenthal | P | MLB | 1991-1992 | 1986-1993 | St. John's |
| Patrick Russell | P | --- | | | --- |
| Marius Russo | P | MLB | 1939-1946 | 1939-1946 | Brooklyn College, Long Island-Brooklyn |
| William Ryan | 3B | A- | | 2001-2001 | Briarcliffe College |
| William Sablesak | OF | A- | | 1978-1978 | --- |
| George Sahadi | 1B | --- | | | --- |
| Rick Saitta | SS | AAA | | 1994-2002 | Rutgers |
| Daniel Saldana | P | Rk | | 1988-1988 | Dominican College |
| Joe Sambito | P | MLB | 1976-1987 | 1976-1988 | Adelphi |
| Cecilio Sanchez | OF | Rk | | 1993-1993 | --- |
| Dylan Sanchez | IF | NCAA | | 2019-2021 | Central Ct State |
| Tommy Sandt | SS-2B | MLB | 1976-1976 | 1976-1993 | --- |
| Marcello Sarrica | P | NCAA | | 2001-2003 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Edmund Savold | P | --- | | | St. Francis (NY) |
| Rich Scalamandre | P | AAA | | 2002-2008 | Dominican College |
| Hal Schacker | P | MLB | 1945-1945 | 1945-1945 | --- |
| John Schappert | P | MLB | 1882-1882 | 1882-1882 | --- |
| Chuck Schilling | 2B | MLB | 1961-1965 | 1961-1965 | Manhattan College |
| Daniel Schirrips | P | --- | | | --- |
| Ted Schreiber | 3B-SS | MLB | 1963-1963 | 1963-1963 | St. John's |
| Pop Schriver | C | MLB | 1886-1901 | 1886-1901 | --- |
| Art Schult | 1B-OF | MLB | 1953-1960 | 1953-1960 | Georgetown |
| Jim Schult | P | Indy | | 2011-2013 | Eastern CT State |
| Anthony Sclafani | P | A | | 1999-2002 | --- |
| Joe Sclafani | SS-3B | AAA | | 2009-2015 | Dartmouth |
| Jim Scudero | P | A+ | | 1983-1984 | New York Tech |
| Frank Seminara | P | MLB | 1992-1994 | 1988-1995 | Columbia |
| John Seneca | P | A- | | 1978-1979 | Seton Hall |
| John Serrano | OF | NCAA | | 2015-2015 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Ted Serro | P | A+ | | 2006-2009 | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Al Severinsen | P | MLB | 1969-1972 | 1969-1972 | Wagner |
| Chuck Sheerin | 2B-3B | MLB | 1936-1936 | 1936-1936 | Fordham |
| Red Sheridan | SS-2B | MLB | 1918-1920 | 1918-1920 | --- |
| Pete Silletti | OF | A- | | 1994-1998 | Princeton |
| Hack Simmons | 2B-1B | MLB | 1910-1912 | 1910-1912 | --- |
| Stan Simmons | OF | NCAA | | 2011-2014 | Long Island-Brooklyn, William Penn |
| Richard Simon | P | AAA | | 1986-1994 | St. Francis (NY) |
| Wayne Slater | OF | A- | | 1997-1998 | Bethune-Cookman, Northeast Texas CC |
| Cam Smith | P | AAA | | 1993-2006 | Ithaca College |
| Charlie Smith | 3B | MLB | 1871-1871 | 1871-1871 | --- |
| Dujuan Smith | P | NCAA | | 2009-2011 | Grambling State |
| Fred Smith | P | A | | 1992-1993 | Connors State College |
| Leo Smith | SS | MLB | 1890-1890 | 1890-1890 | --- |
| Jim Snyder | SS | MLB | 1872-1872 | 1872-1872 | --- |
| Josh Snyder | OF | MLB | 1872-1872 | 1872-1872 | --- |
| Kevin Solano | OF | NCAA | | 2001-2004 | Stony Brook, Coppin State College |
| Bill Sommers | 3B-2B | MLB | 1950-1950 | 1950-1950 | --- |
| Andy Sommerville | P | MLB | 1894-1894 | 1894-1894 | --- |
| Frank Sommo | C | --- | | | Marist |
| Edwardo Soto | P | A+ | | 1985-1987 | Miami Dade |
| John Spelaliere | SS | --- | | | --- |
| Carmine Sperto | P | A | | 1981-1982 | --- |
| Paul Stabile | P | A+ | | 1997-2000 | Brookdale CC |
| Matt Stalter | SS | NCAA | | 2015-2018 | New Jersey Tech, Moravian College |
| Ed Stanko | 1B | A- | | 1985-1985 | William and Mary |
| Bill Starr | C | MLB | 1935-1935 | 1935-1935 | --- |
| Eugene Steinbach | C | AA | | 1981-1984 | Georgia Perimeter College |
| Nick Storz | P | NCAA | | 2018-2020 | LSU |
| Aaron Straker | OF | NCAA | | 2019-2020 | Savannah State |
| Stephen Strauber | P | Rk | | 1986-1986 | State U. College at Fredonia |
| Keith Strickland | P | Indy | | 2001-2004 | South Florida |
| Terrence Stubbs | P | NCAA | | 2011-2013 | Alcorn State, New Mexico JC |
| Brian Sullivan | DH-CF | A | | 1991-1993 | Fordham |
| Jermaine Swinton | 1B | A+ | | 1990-2003 | --- |
| Michael Tansey | OF | Indy | | 2006-2009 | Stony Brook |
| Chris Tavares | OF | Indy | | 2016-2016 | --- |
| Tommy Tavarez | IF | --- | | | Pittsburgh |
| Frank Tepedino | 1B | MLB | 1967-1975 | 1967-1975 | --- |
| Marc Tepper | 1B | A+ | | 1988-1991 | Lubbock Christian |
| Randy Thorpe | OF | Rk | | 1981-1981 | Texas-Arlington |
| Johnathon Tineo | IF | NCAA | | 2014-2014 | Grambling State |
| Al Toledo | P | NCAA | | 1987-1987 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Frank Torre | 1B | MLB | 1956-1963 | 1956-1963 | --- |
| Joe Torre | C-1B | MLB | 1960-1977 | 1960-1977 | --- |
| David Torres | P | A- | | 2003-2004 | Central Florida |
| Isaiah Torres | OF | NCAA | | 2017-2019 | Grambling State, Monroe CC |
| Joe Torres | IF-OF | NCAA | | 2011-2014 | Iona College |
| Jordan Torres | IF | NCAA | | 2018-2018 | Maryland-Eastern Shore |
| Mike Torres | IF | Indy | | 2000-2011 | Lamar |
| Ray Torres | C | Rk | | 2020-2021 | San Jacinto |
| Fred Treacey | OF | MLB | 1871-1876 | 1871-1876 | --- |
| Pete Treacey | SS | MLB | 1876-1876 | 1876-1876 | --- |
| Steve Trella | P | AA | | 1977-1977 | Fullerton College |
| Overton Tremper | OF | MLB | 1927-1928 | 1927-1928 | Pennsylvania |
| Alex Trezza | C-1B | A+ | | 2000-2012 | Stony Brook |
| Luca Trigiani | IF | NCAA | | 2020-2021 | Saint Joseph's |
| Matt Troisi | IF | NCAA | | 2009-2013 | Manhattan College |
| Karl Turetsky | P | --- | | | Marywood, Lackawanna College |
| Hilario Valdespino | 3B | --- | | | Miami Dade |
| Eric Valdez | P | A- | | 2009-2010 | Indiana State, Clarendon College |
| John Valentine | P | MLB | 1883-1883 | 1883-1883 | --- |
| Ike Van Zandt | P | MLB | 1901-1905 | 1901-1905 | --- |
| Roberto Vaz | OF | AAA | | 1997-2003 | Northeast Texas CC, Alabama |
| Roberto Vazquez | 3B | A- | | 1997-1998 | Westmar University |
| Daniel Venezia | SS | A+ | | 1993-1995 | Concordia College |
| Philip Venturino | P | AAA | | 1985-1995 | --- |
| Frank Verdi | SS | --- | | | --- |
| Nelson Villalobos | P | Indy | | 2000-2003 | Hofstra |
| Tony Von Fricken | P | MLB | 1890-1890 | 1890-1890 | --- |
| Oscar Walker | OF-1B | MLB | 1875-1885 | 1875-1885 | --- |
| Joe Wall | C | MLB | 1901-1902 | 1901-1902 | --- |
| Garrett Weir | OF | Indy | | 2001-2006 | Delaware State, Seton Hall |
| Mickey Welch | P | MLB | 1880-1892 | 1880-1892 | --- |
| Andy Wells | P | Indy | | 2006-2012 | Siena College, Wagner |
| Richard Westover | P | A+ | | 1996-1999 | --- |
| Lou Whitaker | 2B | MLB | 1977-1995 | 1977-1995 | --- |
| Mike White | OF | NCAA | | 2012-2015 | Louisville |
| Preston White | OF | --- | | | --- |
| Youman Wilder | 2B | --- | | | California |
| Bill Williams | UMP | --- | | | --- |
| Dallas Williams | OF | MLB | 1981-1983 | 1977-1987 | --- |
| James Williams | P | NCAA | | 2004-2004 | Norfolk State, Fulton-Montgomery CC |
| Tug Wilson | OF-C | MLB | 1884-1884 | 1884-1884 | --- |
| Lave Winham | P | MLB | 1902-1903 | 1902-1903 | --- |
| James Wong | 2B | Indy | | 2013-2013 | Nassau CC, Post U. |
| Jimmy Wood | 2B | MLB | 1871-1873 | 1871-1873 | --- |
| Herb Worth | OF | MLB | 1872-1872 | 1872-1872 | --- |
| John Yeglinski | OF | AA | | 1977-1978 | Long Island-Brooklyn |
| Larry Yellen | P | MLB | 1963-1964 | 1963-1964 | C.W. Post Campus/Long Island |
| Robert Yodice | C | --- | | | --- |
| Ronald York | OF | Rk | | 1991-1991 | South Carolina State |
| Tom York | OF | MLB | 1871-1885 | 1871-1885 | --- |
| Eddie Yost | 3B | MLB | 1944-1962 | 1944-1962 | New York |
| George Young | H | MLB | 1913-1913 | 1913-1913 | --- |
| Chink Zachary | P | MLB | 1944-1944 | 1944-1944 | --- |
| Michael Zamora | UT | NCAA | | 2019-2021 | Texas Southern, Alvin CC |
| Mike Zimmerman | P | AAA | | 1988-1999 | South Alabama |
| Richie Zisk | OF | MLB | 1971-1983 | 1971-1983 | Seton Hall |
| DeShawn Ziths | OF | Rk | | 1997-1997 | Columbia Greene CC |
| Sam Zoldak | P | MLB | 1944-1952 | 1944-1952 | Fordham |
| 621 record(s) |
