| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Baltimore Orioles | 11 | Boston Red Sox | 10 | Box | Billy Loes (2-7) | Dave Sisler (6-7) | BAL B Boyd (1), G Hatton (1) BOS J Piersall (11) | Grady Hatton (38.4) |
| Cleveland Indians | 3 | Chicago White Sox | 4 | Box | Jack Harshman (12-9) | Hank Aguirre (2-3) | CHA M Minoso (13) CLE A Rosen (14) | Minnie Minoso (32.8) |
| KC1 UNBRIDGED | 1 | Detroit Tigers | 3 | Box | Billy Hoeft (16-12) | Art Ditmar (10-19) | None | Jim Small (37.4) |
| New York Yankees | 3 | Washington Senators | 4 | Box | Bud Byerly (2-3) | Tommy Byrne (7-3) | None | Jose Valdivielso (35.9) |
| Chicago Cubs | 2 | Cincinnati Reds | 3 | Box | Joe Nuxhall (11-8) | Moe Drabowsky (1-2) | None | George Crowe (25.7) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 3 | MLN UNBRIDGED | 6 | Box | Bob Trowbridge (3-0) | Larry Jackson (1-2) | MLN J Logan (12) SLN R Katt (12) | Bill Bruton (18.1) |
| BRO UNBRIDGED | 1 | NY1 UNBRIDGED | 2 | Box G1 | Johnny Antonelli (9-13) | Carl Erskine (12-8) | BRO J Gilliam (6) | Jim Gilliam (25.1) |
| BRO UNBRIDGED | 1 | NY1 UNBRIDGED | 4 | Box G2 | Al Worthington (5-11) | Sandy Koufax (2-4) | BRO J Robinson (9) NY1 F Castleman (10), W Mays (24) | Foster Castleman (28.8) |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 6 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 10 | Box G1 | Vern Law (5-10) | Curt Simmons (11-9) | PHI S Hemus (2) PIT F Thomas (15) | Curt Simmons (11.7) |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 1 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 5 | Box G2 | Cholly Naranjo (1-1) | Robin Roberts (15-16) | None | Dale Long (20.1) |