| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Chicago White Sox | 6 | Detroit Tigers | 1 | Box | Dick Donovan (5-7) | Paul Foytack (9-9) | CHA N Fox (3) DET A Kaline (23) | Minnie Minoso (20.6) |
| Cleveland Indians | 11 | KC1 UNBRIDGED | 0 | Box | Bob Lemon (15-9) | Wally Burnette (2-3) | CLE J Busby (11), R Colavito (11), P Ward (6) | Jim Hegan (18.4) |
| Baltimore Orioles | 4 | New York Yankees | 5 | Box | Tom Sturdivant (10-6) | Billy Loes (1-6) | BAL B Nieman (12), D Williams (8) | Bob Nieman (39.1) |
| Boston Red Sox | 3 | Washington Senators | 2 | Box | Tom Brewer (16-4) | Chuck Stobbs (10-9) | BOS D Gernert (12), S White (5), T Williams (14) WS1 J Lemon (17) | Dick Gernert (41.1) |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 3 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 2 | Box | Jack Meyer (7-5) | Sal Maglie (5-4) | BRO G Hodges (23) | Ted Kazanski (24.9) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 4 | Chicago Cubs | 3 | Box | Vinegar Bend Mizell (11-8) | Warren Hacker (1-9) | CHN P Whisenant (8) SLN B Morgan (3), S Musial (20) | Stan Musial (19.1) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 8 | MLN UNBRIDGED | 1 | Box | Larry Jansen (1-0) | Ray Crone (8-5) | CIN E Bailey (20) | Roy McMillan (42.2) |
| NY1 UNBRIDGED | 2 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 3 | Box | Bob Friend (12-5) | Dick Littlefield (0-4) | NY1 D Rhodes (7) PIT B Virdon (7) | Bill Virdon (40.9) |