| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| New York Yankees | 13 | Cleveland Indians | 6 | Box | Whitey Ford (14-4) | Bob Lemon (13-8) | CLE R Colavito (7) NYA M Mantle 2 (34), B Martin (6) | Mickey Mantle (22.0) |
| Boston Red Sox | 1 | Detroit Tigers | 4 | Box | Virgil Trucks (5-4) | Frank Sullivan (9-5) | BOS M Vernon (10) | Frank Bolling (22.2) |
| Baltimore Orioles | 4 | KC1 UNBRIDGED | 3 | Box | Mike Fornieles (3-4) | Tom Gorman (7-7) | BAL R Moore (2), B Nieman (10) | Bob Nieman (36.8) |
| MLN UNBRIDGED | 8 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 6 | Box | Bob Buhl (13-4) | Roger Craig (10-6) | BRO P Reese (8) MLN H Aaron (12), J Adcock (19), E Mathews (16) | Joe Adcock (19.4) |
| Chicago Cubs | 4 | Philadelphia Phillies | 5 | Box G1 | Robin Roberts (11-11) | Vito Valentinetti (4-2) | CHN E Banks (21), W Moryn (11) PHI S Lopata (20) | Elmer Valo (39.1) |
| Chicago Cubs | 2 | Philadelphia Phillies | 4 | Box G2 | Harvey Haddix (9-3) | Warren Hacker (1-8) | CHN W Moryn (12) PHI E Valo (5) | Stan Lopata (9.2) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 4 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2 | Box | Hersh Freeman (9-3) | Laurin Pepper (0-1) | None | Gus Bell (18.5) |