| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| New York Yankees | 10 | Chicago White Sox | 1 | Box | Whitey Ford (13-4) | Dick Donovan (4-6) | None | Jerry Coleman (18.2) |
| Washington Senators | 3 | Cleveland Indians | 11 | Box | Herb Score (9-6) | Camilo Pascual (4-12) | CLE B Avila (6), J Hegan (4) WS1 R Sievers (19) | Bobby Avila (22.2) |
| Baltimore Orioles | 2 | Detroit Tigers | 6 | Box | Paul Foytack (8-6) | Morrie Martin (2-1) | DET F House (7), E Torgeson (10) | Earl Torgeson (43.1) |
| Boston Red Sox | 6 | KC1 UNBRIDGED | 9 | Box | Tom Gorman (7-6) | Fritz Dorish (0-1) | KC1 H Simpson (14) | Harry Simpson (54.4) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 1 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 2 | Box | Don Newcombe (14-5) | Brooks Lawrence (14-2) | BRO C Furillo (12), D Snider (24) CIN F Robinson (22) | Carl Furillo (21.6) |
| MLN UNBRIDGED | 7 | NY1 UNBRIDGED | 4 | Box | Bob Buhl (12-4) | Al Worthington (4-11) | MLN E Mathews (15), B Thomson (10) NY1 B White (12) | Bobby Thomson (57.5) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 8 | Philadelphia Phillies | 7 | Box | Larry Jackson (1-0) | Ron Negray (1-2) | PHI D Ennis (17), G Hamner (4), S Lopata (18) | Granny Hamner (52.7) |