| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Cleveland Indians | 9 | Boston Red Sox | 10 | Box | Ike Delock (2-4) | Bob Lemon (7-4) | BOS J Jensen (7) CLE B Lemon (2) | Dick Gernert (43.9) |
| Chicago White Sox | 1 | New York Yankees | 5 | Box | Bob Grim (4-0) | Jim Wilson (8-3) | CHA D Philley (2) NYA M Mantle (22) | Mickey Mantle (16.7) |
| NY1 UNBRIDGED | 2 | MLN UNBRIDGED | 5 | Box | Warren Spahn (4-5) | Ruben Gomez (2-5) | MLN D Crandall (11) NY1 W Mays (8) | Del Crandall (35.9) |