| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| New York Yankees | 6 | Chicago White Sox | 1 | Box G1 | Whitey Ford (15-6) | Connie Johnson (6-3) | CHA W Dropo (18) NYA Y Berra (23), M Mantle (34) | Mickey Mantle (22.3) |
| New York Yankees | 2 | Chicago White Sox | 3 | Box G2 | Billy Pierce (12-8) | Bob Turley (13-13) | CHA B Kennedy (6) | Bob Kennedy (26.1) |
| Washington Senators | 8 | Cleveland Indians | 2 | Box G1 | Chuck Stobbs (3-11) | Art Houtteman (10-6) | WS1 C Courtney (3) | Clint Courtney (26.2) |
| Washington Senators | 13 | Cleveland Indians | 4 | Box G2 | Mickey McDermott (8-8) | Mike Garcia (9-12) | CLE R Kiner (15), A Smith (19) | Ralph Kiner (25.2) |
| Boston Red Sox | 14 | KC1 UNBRIDGED | 2 | Box | Frank Sullivan (16-12) | Vic Raschi (4-6) | BOS G Hatton (4), E Joost 2 (5), T Williams (25) KC1 E Slaughter (4) | Grady Hatton (30.4) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 1 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 6 | Box | Karl Spooner (6-5) | Larry Jackson (4-10) | BRO R Campanella (29), G Hodges (24) SLN R Repulski (19) | Roy Campanella (12.4) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 6 | Philadelphia Phillies | 7 | Box G1 | Bob Miller (7-4) | Joe Nuxhall (14-10) | PHI D Ennis (26), J Greengrass (8), S Lopata (17) | Del Ennis (25.3) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 3 | Philadelphia Phillies | 8 | Box G2 | Ron Negray (4-3) | Jackie Collum (9-8) | CIN S Mele (2) PHI D Ennis (27) | Andy Seminick (16.4) |
| MLN UNBRIDGED | 3 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 5 | Box G1 | Dick Hall (2-3) | Ray Crone (7-8) | MLN E Mathews (29), B Thomson (11) | Jerry Lynch (45.2) |
| MLN UNBRIDGED | 0 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2 | Box G2 | Vern Law (8-6) | Warren Spahn (11-12) | None | Frank Thomas (15.5) |