| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Boston Red Sox | 5 | Baltimore Orioles | 1 | Box | George Susce (3-3) | Don Johnson (1-4) | None | Jim Piersall (17.7) |
| Chicago White Sox | 2 | Cleveland Indians | 1 | Box | Jack Harshman (6-5) | Herb Score (7-6) | CHA J Harshman (2) CLE J Hegan (3) | Jack Harshman (31.3) |
| Detroit Tigers | 10 | KC1 UNBRIDGED | 11 | Box | Johnny Sain (2-4) | Al Aber (4-1) | DET R Boone (10), F Hatfield (5), A Kaline (15) KC1 J DeMaestri (1) | Al Kaline (45.2) |
| Washington Senators | 0 | New York Yankees | 12 | Box | Tommy Byrne (6-2) | Bob Porterfield (7-12) | NYA T Byrne (1), E Howard (6) | Mickey Mantle (13.1) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | 7 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 6 | Box | Ron Kline (4-8) | Clem Labine (6-2) | BRO D Hoak (1), D Snider (25) PIT F Thomas (8) | Johnny O'Brien (28.6) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 3 | Chicago Cubs | 4 | Box | Paul Minner (6-2) | Larry Jackson (2-4) | CHN W Cooper (5), R Jackson (12) SLN P Whisenant (2) | Randy Jackson (25.3) |
| MLN UNBRIDGED | 5 | Cincinnati Reds | 10 | Box | Jackie Collum (7-2) | Chet Nichols (5-5) | CIN T Kluszewski (25) MLN H Aaron (12), J Adcock (6) | Ray Jablonski (28.0) |
| NY1 UNBRIDGED | 6 | Philadelphia Phillies | 1 | Box | Sal Maglie (7-4) | Curt Simmons (4-4) | NY1 S Gordon (2), R Katt (3), W Mays (18) | Sid Gordon (39.2) |