| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| New York Yankees | 9 | Boston Red Sox | 6 | Box | Tom Morgan (2-0) | Ike Delock (2-3) | BOS T Lepcio (4) NYA E Howard (1), M Mantle (6) | Yogi Berra (43.8) |
| Detroit Tigers | 7 | Chicago White Sox | 1 | Box | Steve Gromek (5-1) | Billy Pierce (2-1) | None | Harvey Kuenn (18.1) |
| KC1 UNBRIDGED | 3 | Cleveland Indians | 9 | Box | Early Wynn (2-0) | Bobby Shantz (1-3) | KC1 J Finigan (5) | Bobby Avila (21.6) |
| Baltimore Orioles | 5 | Washington Senators | 1 | Box | Jim Wilson (1-3) | Johnny Schmitz (3-1) | BAL H Evers (4) | Gus Triandos (18.2) |
| Chicago Cubs | 7 | Cincinnati Reds | 8 | Box | Rudy Minarcin (1-0) | Jim Davis (1-1) | CHN H Chiti (4), D Fondy (2), B Speake (1) CIN W Post (5), B Thurman (2) | Bob Thurman (69.8) |
| BRO UNBRIDGED | 6 | Philadelphia Phillies | 3 | Box | Carl Erskine (5-0) | Robin Roberts (3-3) | PHI D Ennis (5), W Jones 2 (6) | Willie Jones (14.8) |