| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| PHA UNBRIDGED | 0 | Baltimore Orioles | 2 | Box | Joe Coleman (2-2) | Arnie Portocarrero (0-2) | None | Vern Stephens (9.4) |
| Boston Red Sox | 1 | Chicago White Sox | 2 | Box | Bob Keegan (4-1) | Frank Sullivan (0-1) | None | Johnny Groth (17.0) |
| New York Yankees | 5 | Cleveland Indians | 3 | Box | Allie Reynolds (3-1) | Dave Hoskins (0-1) | None | Yogi Berra (51.1) |
| Washington Senators | 5 | Detroit Tigers | 3 | Box | Bob Porterfield (3-2) | Al Aber (0-1) | DET F House (1) WS1 B Porterfield (1), E Yost (2) | Mickey Vernon (24.8) |
| MLN UNBRIDGED | 2 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 0 | Box | Gene Conley (2-1) | Russ Meyer (2-1) | MLN J Adcock (4) | Joe Adcock (22.0) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 4 | NY1 UNBRIDGED | 5 | Box | Marv Grissom (2-0) | Fred Baczewski (2-2) | CIN T Kluszewski (10) NY1 W Lockman (4), W Mays (6) | Bobby Adams (43.7) |
| Chicago Cubs | 7 | Philadelphia Phillies | 8 | Box | Steve Ridzik (1-1) | Turk Lown (0-1) | None | Randy Jackson (37.8) |