| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Cleveland Indians | 1 | Baltimore Orioles | 2 | Box | Bob Turley (3-2) | Art Houtteman (1-2) | None | Dick Kryhoski (11.1) |
| Detroit Tigers | 3 | Chicago White Sox | 2 | Box G1 | Steve Gromek (5-0) | Virgil Trucks (3-2) | CHA S Lollar (3) | Harvey Kuenn (26.1) |
| PHA UNBRIDGED | 4 | New York Yankees | 7 | Box G1 | Harry Byrd (1-3) | Bob Trice (4-1) | NYA Y Berra (5), A Carey (1), E Slaughter (1) PHA B Shantz (1) | Andy Carey (34.1) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 10 | Cincinnati Reds | 7 | Box G1 | Vic Raschi (2-0) | Howie Judson (1-3) | CIN J Greengrass (4), T Kluszewski (7) SLN S Musial (10), D Rice (1) | Stan Musial (24.2) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 5 | Cincinnati Reds | 6 | Box G2 | Bud Podbielan (2-1) | Stu Miller (0-1) | CIN T Kluszewski 2 (9) SLN C Deal (1), S Hemus (1) | Ted Kluszewski (25.6) |
| Chicago Cubs | 5 | MLN UNBRIDGED | 3 | Box | Bob Rush (2-2) | Warren Spahn (3-2) | CHN R Kiner (4), H Sauer (8) | Hank Sauer (19.7) |
| BRO UNBRIDGED | 2 | Philadelphia Phillies | 1 | Box | Carl Erskine (3-2) | Robin Roberts (3-3) | None | Sandy Amoros (22.1) |