| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Cleveland Indians | 0 | New York Yankees | 1 | Box | Allie Reynolds (2-3) | Early Wynn (2-4) | None | Phil Rizzuto (10.0) |
| SLA UNBRIDGED | 6 | PHA UNBRIDGED | 7 | Box | Bobby Shantz (2-2) | Al Widmar (2-2) | PHA G Zernial (5) | Don Lenhardt (21.2) |
| Detroit Tigers | 6 | Washington Senators | 11 | Box | Connie Marrero (5-0) | Fred Hutchinson (2-1) | None | Mike McCormick (20.7) |
| BRO UNBRIDGED | 0 | Chicago Cubs | 7 | Box | Frank Hiller (4-2) | Erv Palica (1-2) | CHN R Jackson (3), H Sauer (7) | Hank Sauer (33.8) |
| BSN UNBRIDGED | 5 | Cincinnati Reds | 6 | Box | Willie Ramsdell (2-4) | Warren Spahn (3-3) | BSN S Gordon (5) CIN C Ryan (3) | Johnny Wyrostek (18.9) |
| NY1 UNBRIDGED | 7 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 12 | Box | Murry Dickson (5-2) | Monty Kennedy (0-1) | NY1 D Mueller (1) PIT R Kiner (6), W Westlake (6) | Ralph Kiner (48.1) |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 1 | St. Louis Cardinals | 2 | Box | Joe Presko (2-2) | Robin Roberts (3-3) | PHI A Seminick (2) | Nippy Jones (13.8) |