| Vis | Home | Box | Winning Pitcher | Losing pitcher | Home Runs | Best Hitter Impact | ||
| Cleveland Indians | 2 | Detroit Tigers | 1 | Box | Bob Lemon (1-0) | Hal Newhouser (0-1) | None | Jim Hegan (47.9) |
| Boston Red Sox | 0 | New York Yankees | 5 | Box | Vic Raschi (1-0) | Bill Wight (0-1) | NYA J Jensen (1) | Yogi Berra (8.2) |
| Washington Senators | 6 | PHA UNBRIDGED | 1 | Box | Connie Marrero (1-0) | Bobby Shantz (0-1) | WS1 M Grasso (1) | Mickey Grasso (24.1) |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 5 | BRO UNBRIDGED | 2 | Box | Robin Roberts (1-0) | Carl Erskine (0-1) | BRO J Robinson (1) PHI D Ennis (1), M Goliat (1) | Del Ennis (19.6) |
| NY1 UNBRIDGED | 4 | BSN UNBRIDGED | 0 | Box | Larry Jansen (1-0) | Vern Bickford (0-1) | None | Wes Westrum (17.0) |
| Cincinnati Reds | 3 | Chicago Cubs | 8 | Box | Frank Hiller (1-0) | Ken Raffensberger (0-1) | CHN A Pafko (1) | Dee Fondy (19.2) |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 4 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 5 | Box | Murry Dickson (1-0) | Tom Poholsky (0-1) | PIT M Dickson (1), W Westlake (1) | Wally Westlake (32.1) |