Yearly RecordS = Statistics D = Draft Picks R = Rosters O = Organizational Rosters Box = Boxscores
| 1998 | NYPL | Pinckney | S - R | 42 | 34 | .553 | 3.0 | 3 | CLE | Ted Kubiak | dnq | | 1997 | NYPL | Pinckney | S - R | 39 | 36 | .520 | 10.0 | 2 | CLE | Ted Kubiak | dnq | | 1996 | NYPL | Pinckney | S - R | 45 | 30 | .600 | - | 1 | CLE | Ted Kubiak | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 1995 | NYPL | Stedler | S - R | 46 | 27 | .630 | - | 1 | CLE | Joel Skinner | League Champions | | 1994 | NYPL | Pinckney | S - R | 48 | 26 | .649 | - | 1 | CLE | Jeff Datz | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 1993 | NYPL | Pinckney | S - R | 46 | 32 | .590 | - | 1 | CLE | Mike Young | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 1992 | NYPL | McNamara | S - R | 37 | 39 | .487 | 6.0 | 4 | CLE | Shawn Pender | dnq | | 1991 | NYPL | McNamara-East | S - R | 27 | 50 | .351 | 24.0 | 4 | CLE | Gary Tuck, Jim Gabella | dnq | | 1990 | NYPL | Eastern | S - R | 43 | 34 | .558 | 8.5 | 3 | CLE | Jim Gabella | dnq | | 1989 | NYPL | Eastern | S - R | 47 | 30 | .610 | 6.5 | 3 | CLE | Brian Graham | dnq | | 1988 | NYPL | Eastern | S - R | 35 | 39 | .473 | 12.0 | 5 | PIT | Stan Cliburn | dnq | | 1987 | NYPL | Eastern | S - R | 44 | 32 | .579 | - | 1 | PIT | Jeff Cox | Lost in Finals | | 1986 | NYPL | Yawkey | S - R | 30 | 48 | .385 | 29.5 | 3 | PIT | Ed Ott | dnq | | 1985 | NYPL | Northern | S - R | 22 | 54 | .289 | 32.0 | 4 | PIT | Woody Hunt | dnq | | 1984 | NYPL | Eastern | S - R | 39 | 35 | .527 | 4.5 | 2 | PIT | Bill Bryk | dnq | | 1983 | NYPL | Eastern | S - R | 21 | 55 | .276 | 27.5 | 6 | PIT | Bill Bryk | dnq |
| 