Yearly RecordS = Statistics D = Draft Picks R = Rosters O = Organizational Rosters Box = Boxscores
| 2009 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 54 | 84 | .391 | 39.0 | 6 | TOR | | dnq | | 2008 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 76 | 64 | .543 | - | 1 | TOR | Clayton McCullough | Lost in 1st Round | | 2007 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 78 | 61 | .561 | 4.5 | 2 | TOR | Gary Cathcart | Lost in 1st Round | | 2006 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 72 | 65 | .526 | 17.0 | 3 | TOR | - | Lost in 2nd Round | | 2005 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 70 | 69 | .504 | 13.5 | 4 | TOR | Ken Navarrette | dnq | | 2004 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 77 | 63 | .550 | - | 1 | CHC | Julio Garcia | Lost in 1st Round | | 2003 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 69 | 66 | .511 | 3.0 | 4 | CHC | Julio Garcia | League Champions | | 2002 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 74 | 65 | .532 | 8.5 | 3 | CHC | Julio Garcia | Lost in Finals | | 2001 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 65 | 75 | .464 | 18.5 | 5 | CHC | Julio Garcia | Lost in 1st Round | | 2000 | Midw | - | S - R | 70 | 68 | .507 | | | CHC | | dnq | | 1999 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 73 | 67 | .521 | 4.0 | 2 | CHC | Oscar Acosta | Lost in Semi-Finals | | 1998 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 71 | 69 | .507 | 12.0 | 4 | KC | Bob Herold | dnq | | 1997 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 69 | 68 | .504 | 26.0 | 3 | KC | Bob Herold | League Champions | | 1996 | Midw | Eastern | S - R | 68 | 71 | .489 | 9.5 | 3 | KC | Brian Polbert | Lost in First Round |
| 
