| Year | Team Name | League | Division | Affilate | W | L | Pct | Rank | Managers | Stadium | Playoffs | |
| 2013 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | ATL | 36 | 33 | .522 | 2 | Luis Salazar | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2012 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | ATL | 72 | 68 | .514 | 1 | Luis Salazar | Calvin Falwell Field | League Champions |
| 2011 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | ATL | 60 | 78 | .435 | 4 | Luis Salazar | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2010 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | CIN | 61 | 77 | .442 | 4 | Pat Kelly | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2009 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 73 | 66 | .525 | 3 | P.J. Forbes | Calvin Falwell Field | League Champions |
| 2008 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 58 | 80 | .420 | 4 | Jeff Branson | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2007 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 55 | 82 | .401 | 4 | Jeff Branson | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2006 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 63 | 75 | .457 | 3 | Gary Green | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2005 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 78 | 62 | .557 | 2 | Tim Leiper | Calvin Falwell Field | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 2004 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 57 | 81 | .413 | 3 | Jay Loviglio | Calvin Falwell Field | dnq |
| 2003 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 76 | 59 | .563 | 1 | Dave Clark | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Finals |
| 2002 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 87 | 53 | .621 | 2 | Pete Mackanin | Lynchburg City Stadium | League Champions |
| 2001 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 58 | 79 | .423 | 4 | Curtis Wilkerson | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 2000 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 66 | 72 | .478 | 2 | Tracy Woodson | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Finals |
| 1999 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 64 | 73 | .467 | 3 | Scott Little | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1998 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 69 | 71 | .493 | 3 | Jeff Livesey Jeff Richardson | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1997 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 82 | 58 | .586 | 1 | Jeff Banister Jeff Richardson | Lynchburg City Stadium | League Champions |
| 1996 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 65 | 74 | .468 | 3 | Jeff Banister | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1995 | Lynchburg | Hillcats | Caro | Northern | PIT | 67 | 71 | .486 | 3 | Marc Hill | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1994 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 52 | 87 | .374 | 4 | Mark Meleski | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1993 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 65 | 74 | .468 | 4 | Mark Meleski | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1992 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 39 | 30 | .565 | 1 | Buddy Bailey | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Finals |
| 1991 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 67 | 72 | .482 | 2 | Buddy Bailey | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Finals |
| 1990 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 58 | 80 | .420 | 3 | Gary Allenson | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1989 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 70 | 66 | .515 | 3 | Gary Allenson | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 1988 | Lynchburg | Red Sox | Caro | Northern | BOS | 68 | 72 | .486 | 3 | Dick Berardino | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Finals (Kinston) |
| 1987 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 63 | 76 | .453 | 4 | John Tamargo | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1986 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 75 | 65 | .536 | 2 | Bobby Floyd | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1985 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 95 | 45 | .679 | 1 | Mike Cubbage | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Finals |
| 1984 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 89 | 49 | .645 | 1 | Mike Cubbage | Lynchburg City Stadium | League Champions |
| 1983 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 96 | 43 | .691 | 1 | Sam Perlozzo | Lynchburg City Stadium | League Champions |
| 1982 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 65 | 71 | .478 | 3 | Dan Monzon | Lynchburg City Stadium | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 1981 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Northern | NYM | 71 | 69 | .507 | 1 | Gene Dusan | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1980 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | Virginia | NYM | 71 | 68 | .511 | 3 | Jack Aker | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1979 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | - | NYM | 61 | 73 | .455 | 5 | Jack Aker | Lynchburg City Stadium | dnq |
| 1978 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | - | NYM | 73 | 64 | .533 | 2 | Jack Aker | Lynchburg City Stadium | League Champions |
| 1977 | Lynchburg | Mets | Caro | - | NYM | 78 | 60 | .565 | 1 | dnq | ||