| Year | Team Name | League | Division | Affilate | W | L | Pct | Rank | Managers | Stadium | Playoffs | |
| 1997 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | CLE | 87 | 57 | .604 | 1 | Brian Graham | North AmeriCare Park | League Champions |
| 1996 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | CLE | 84 | 60 | .583 | 1 | Brian Graham | North AmeriCare Park | Lost in Semi-Finals |
| 1995 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | - | CLE | 82 | 62 | .569 | 2 | Brian Graham | North AmeriCare Park | Lost in Finals |
| 1994 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | - | PIT | 55 | 89 | .382 | 8 | Doc Edwards | Downtown Ballpark | dnq |
| 1993 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | PIT | 71 | 73 | .493 | 2 | Doc Edwards | Pilot Field | dnq |
| 1992 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | PIT | 87 | 57 | .604 | 1 | Marc Bombard | Pilot Field | Lost in Finals |
| 1991 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | PIT | 81 | 62 | .566 | 1 | Terry Collins | Pilot Field | Lost in Finals |
| 1990 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | PIT | 85 | 62 | .578 | Terry Collins | Pilot Field | dnq | |
| 1989 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | PIT | 80 | 62 | .563 | 2 | Terry Collins | Pilot Field | dnq |
| 1988 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | PIT | 72 | 70 | .507 | 3 | Rocky Bridges | Pilot Field | dnq |
| 1987 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | - | CLE | 66 | 74 | .471 | 5 | Orlando Gomez Steve Swisher | War Memorial Stadium | dnq |
| 1986 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | CHW | 71 | 71 | .500 | 2 | Jim Marshall | War Memorial Stadium | dnq |
| 1985 | Buffalo | Bisons | Amer | Eastern | CHW | 66 | 76 | .465 | 3 | John Boles | War Memorial Stadium | dnq |