| East | W | L | Pct | GB |
| NY Yankees | 101 | 61 | .623 | -- |
| Boston | 95 | 67 | .586 | 6.0 |
| Toronto | 86 | 76 | .531 | 15.0 |
| Baltimore | 71 | 91 | .438 | 30.0 |
| Tampa Bay | 63 | 99 | .389 | 38.0 |
| Phase | Rnd | Ovl | Player | Pos | Current Status |
| June-Reg | 1 | 13 | Aaron Hill | SS | ARI Minors (DL-15) 40m |
| June-Reg | 2 | 50 | Josh Banks | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 3 | 80 | Shaun Marcum | P | NYM 40m |
| June-Reg | 4 | 110 | Kurt Isenberg | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 5 | 140 | Justin James | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 6 | 170 | Christian Snavely | OF | Retired |
| June-Reg | 7 | 200 | Danny Core | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 8 | 230 | Chad Mulholland | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 9 | 260 | Jamie Vermilyea | P | Manager - Maui Na Koa (2012) |
| June-Reg | 10 | 290 | Jayce Tingler | OF | Retired |
| June-Reg | 11 | 320 | Tom Mastny | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 12 | 350 | Jayson Rodriguez | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 13 | 380 | Matt Foster | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 14 | 410 | Jeremy Harper | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 15 | 440 | Vito Chiaravalloti | 1B | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 16 | 470 | Joey Reiman | C | Retired |
| June-Reg | 17 | 500 | Jordy Templet | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 18 | 530 | Ryan Roberts | 3B | TB 40m |
| June-Reg | 19 | 560 | Adrian Martin | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 20 | 590 | Brad Depoy | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 21 | 620 | Mark Sopko | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 22 | 650 | Vinny Esposito | 3B | Retired |
| June-Reg | 23 | 680 | Jermy Acey | 2B | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 24 | 710 | Nick Evangelista | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 25 | 740 | Brian Patrick | 2B | Retired |
| June-Reg | 26 | 770 | Kyle Thousand | OF | Retired |
| June-Reg | 27 | 800 | Brian Reed | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 28 | 830 | Patrick Breen | OF | Retired |
| June-Reg | 29 | 860 | Ben Nieto | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 30 | 890 | Billy Wheeler | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 31 | 920 | Joaquin Canizal | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 32 | 950 | Brad Mumma | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 33 | 980 | Joey Wolfe | C | Retired |
| June-Reg | 34 | 1010 | Jeremy Noegel | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 35 | 1040 | Jim Burt | 1B | Retired |
| June-Reg | 36 | 1070 | Matt Trink | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 37 | 1100 | Aric Van Gaalen | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 38 | 1130 | Jack Ryser | OF | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 39 | 1160 | William Blackmon | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 40 | 1190 | Jimmy Coker | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 41 | 1220 | Scott Tolbert | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 42 | 1249 | Jeremy Knicely | C | Retired |
| June-Reg | 43 | 1278 | Ryan Gordon | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 44 | 1306 | Brent Johnson | OF | Assistant Coach - Arizona Mariners (2012) |
| June-Reg | 45 | 1333 | Paul Franko | 1B | Retired |
| June-Reg | 46 | 1360 | Paul Marlow | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 47 | 1387 | Jeff Walker | P | Inactive |
| June-Reg | 48 | 1414 | Bryan Hansen | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 49 | 1440 | Michael Rider | P | Retired |
| June-Reg | 50 | 1466 | Angel Hernandez | OF | Inactive |