| 19 | Don Blasingame | 2B | MLB | 5-10 | 165 | Left | Right | 3/16/1932 | 31 | Corinth,Mississippi | | UDFA | | |
|
| 11 | Harry Bright | 1B-3B | MLB | 6-0 | 190 | Right | Right | 9/22/1929 | 33 | Kansas City,Missouri | | UDFA | | |
| 42 | Jim Brosnan | P | MLB | 6-4 | 210 | Right | Right | 10/24/1929 | 33 | Cincinnati,Ohio | | UDFA | | |
| 16 | Leo Cardenas | SS | MLB | 5-10 | 163 | Right | Right | 12/17/1938 | 24 | Matanza,Cuba | 1957 | UDFA | | CIN |
| 47 | Jim Coates | P | MLB | 6-4 | 192 | Right | Right | 8/4/1932 | 30 | Farnham,Virginia | | UDFA | | |
| 18 | Gordy Coleman | 1B | MLB | 6-2 | 218 | Left | Right | 7/5/1934 | 28 | Rockville,Maryland | | UDFA | | |
| 6 | Johnny Edwards | C | MLB | 6-4 | 220 | Left | Right | 6/10/1938 | 25 | Columbus,Ohio | 1959 | UDFA | | CIN |
| 9 | Hank Foiles | C | MLB | 6-0 | 195 | Right | Right | 6/10/1929 | 34 | Richmond,Virginia | | UDFA | | |
| 12 | Gene Freese | 3B | MLB | 5-11 | 175 | Right | Right | 1/8/1934 | 29 | Wheeling,West Virginia | | UDFA | | |
| 7 | Jesse Gonder | C | MLB | 5-10 | 190 | Left | Right | 1/20/1936 | 27 | Monticello,Arkansas | | UDFA | | |
| 9 | Gene Green | C-OF | MLB | 6-2 | 205 | Right | Right | 6/26/1933 | 30 | Los Angeles,California | | UDFA | | |
| 17 | Tommy Harper | OF-3B | MLB | 5-10 | 168 | Right | Right | 10/14/1940 | 22 | Oak Grove,Louisiana | 1960 | UDFA | | CIN |
| 44 | Bill Henry | P | MLB | 6-2 | 180 | Left | Left | 10/15/1927 | 35 | Alice,Texas | | UDFA | | |
| 30 | Joey Jay | P | MLB | 6-4 | 228 | Both | Right | 8/15/1935 | 27 | Middletown,Connecticut | | UDFA | | |
| 10 | Eddie Kasko | SS-3B | MLB | 6-0 | 180 | Right | Right | 6/27/1932 | 31 | Linden,New Jersey | | UDFA | | |
| 25 | Marty Keough | OF-1B | MLB | 6-0 | 180 | Left | Left | 4/14/1935 | 28 | Oakland,California | | UDFA | | |
| 24 | Jerry Lynch | OF | MLB | 6-1 | 189 | Left | Right | 7/17/1930 | 32 | Bay City,Michigan | | UDFA | | |
| 46 | Jim Maloney | P | MLB | 6-2 | 207 | Left | Right | 6/2/1940 | 23 | Fresno,California | | UDFA | | |
| 19 | Charlie Neal | 2B-SS | MLB | 5-10 | 165 | Right | Right | 1/30/1931 | 32 | Longview,Texas | | UDFA | | |
| 41 | Joe Nuxhall | P | MLB | 6-3 | 219 | Left | Left | 7/30/1928 | 34 | Hamilton,Ohio | | UDFA | | |
| 31 | Jim O'Toole | P | MLB | 6-0 | 198 | Both | Left | 1/10/1937 | 26 | Chicago,Illinois | | UDFA | | |
| 48 | Jim Owens | P | MLB | 5-11 | 190 | Right | Right | 1/16/1934 | 29 | Gifford,Pennsylvania | | UDFA | | |
| 8 | Don Pavletich | C-1B | MLB | 5-11 | 209 | Right | Right | 7/13/1938 | 24 | Milwaukee,Wisconsin | | UDFA | | |
| 28 | Vada Pinson | OF | MLB | 5-11 | 181 | Left | Left | 8/11/1938 | 24 | Memphis,Tennessee | 1956 | UDFA | | CIN |
| 29 | Wally Post | OF | MLB | 6-1 | 203 | Right | Right | 7/9/1929 | 33 | St. Wendelin,Ohio | | UDFA | | |
| 37 | Bob Purkey | P | MLB | 6-2 | 195 | Right | Right | 7/14/1929 | 33 | Pittsburgh,Pennsylvania | | UDFA | | |
| 20 | Frank Robinson | OF | MLB | 6-1 | 195 | Right | Right | 8/31/1935 | 27 | Beaumont,Texas | 1953 | UDFA | | CIN |
| 14 | Pete Rose | OF-1B | MLB | 5-11 | 203 | Both | Right | 4/14/1941 | 22 | Cincinnati,Ohio | 1960 | UDFA | | CIN |
| 24 | Bob Skinner | OF | MLB | 6-4 | 190 | Left | Right | 10/3/1931 | 31 | La Jolla,California | | UDFA | | |
| 9 | Daryl Spencer | SS-2B | MLB | 6-2 | 190 | Right | Right | 7/13/1929 | 33 | Wichita,Kansas | | UDFA | | |
| 7 | Sammy Taylor | C | MLB | 6-2 | 185 | Left | Right | 2/27/1933 | 30 | Woodruff,South Carolina | | UDFA | | |
| 38 | John Tsitouris | P | MLB | 6-0 | 175 | Right | Right | 5/4/1936 | 27 | Monroe,North Carolina | | UDFA | | |
| 21 | Ken Walters | OF | MLB | 6-1 | 180 | Right | Right | 11/11/1933 | 29 | Fresno,California | | UDFA | | |
| 33 | Al Worthington | P | MLB | 6-2 | 205 | Right | Right | 2/5/1929 | 34 | Birmingham,Alabama | | UDFA | | |
| 43 | Dom Zanni | P | MLB | 5-11 | 180 | Right | Right | 3/1/1932 | 31 | Bronx,New York | | UDFA | | |