| - | Jimmy Collins | 3B | MLB | 5-9 | 178 | Right | Right | 1/16/1870 | 34 | Buffalo,New York | | UDFA | | |
|
| - | Lou Criger | C | MLB | 5-10 | 165 | Right | Right | 2/3/1872 | 32 | Elkhart,Indiana | | UDFA | | |
| - | Bill Dinneen | P | MLB | 6-1 | 190 | Right | Right | 4/5/1876 | 28 | Syracuse,New York | | UDFA | | |
| - | Tom Doran | C | MLB | 5-11 | 152 | Left | Right | 12/2/1880 | 23 | Westchester County,New York | | UDFA | | |
| - | Patsy Dougherty | OF | MLB | 6-2 | 190 | Left | Right | 10/27/1876 | 27 | Andover,New York | | UDFA | | |
| - | Duke Farrell | C | MLB | 6-1 | 208 | Both | Right | 8/31/1866 | 37 | Oakdale,Massachusetts | | UDFA | | |
| - | Hobe Ferris | 2B-3B | MLB | 5-8 | 162 | Right | Right | 12/7/1877 | 26 | Providence,Rhode Island | | UDFA | | |
| - | Buck Freeman | OF-1B | MLB | 5-9 | 169 | Left | Left | 10/30/1871 | 32 | Catasauqua,Pennsylvania | | UDFA | | |
| - | Norwood Gibson | P | MLB | 5-10 | 165 | Right | Right | 3/11/1877 | 27 | Peoria,Illinois | | UDFA | | |
| - | Candy LaChance | 1B | MLB | 6-1 | 183 | Both | Right | 2/15/1870 | 34 | Waterbury,Connecticut | | UDFA | | |
| - | Bill O'Neill | OF | MLB | 5-11 | 175 | Both | Right | 1/22/1880 | 24 | Saint John,New Brunswick | | UDFA | | |
| - | Freddy Parent | SS | MLB | 5-7 | 154 | Right | Right | 11/25/1875 | 28 | Biddeford,Maine | | UDFA | | |
| - | Kip Selbach | OF | MLB | 5-7 | 190 | Right | Right | 3/24/1872 | 32 | Columbus,Ohio | | UDFA | | |
| - | Chick Stahl | OF | MLB | 5-10 | 160 | Left | Left | 1/10/1873 | 31 | Avilla,Indiana | | UDFA | | |
| - | Jesse Tannehill | P | MLB | 5-8 | 150 | Both | Left | 7/14/1874 | 29 | Dayton,Kentucky | | UDFA | | |
| - | Bob Unglaub | 1B | MLB | 5-11 | 178 | Right | Right | 7/31/1881 | 22 | Baltimore,Maryland | | UDFA | | |
| - | George Winter | P | MLB | 5-8 | 155 | Right | Right | 4/27/1878 | 26 | New Providence,Pennsylvania | | UDFA | | |
| - | Cy Young | P | MLB | 6-2 | 210 | Right | Right | 3/29/1867 | 37 | Gilmore,Ohio | | UDFA | | |