| Player | Status | High Level | Played | Born | Place | Ht | Wt | Bats | Throws | Draft Information | |||
| Jayson Best | Retired | AA | 1989-1997 | 9/9/1968 | Lafayette, Indiana | 6-0 | 170 | Right | Right | 1989 | 0 | 0 | MIN |
| Doc Crandall | Deceased | MLB | 1908-1918 | 10/8/1887 | Wadena, Indiana | 5-10 | 180 | Right | Right | ||||
| George Gick | Deceased | MLB | 1937-1938 | 10/18/1915 | Dunnington, Indiana | 6-0 | 190 | Both | Right | ||||
| Ryan Greives | Inactive | - | 5/10/1984 | Otterbein, Indiana | 6-4 | 190 | Right | Right | 2002 | 47 | 1396 | PHI | |
| Otis Johnson | Deceased | MLB | 1911-1911 | 11/5/1883 | Fowler, Indiana | 5-9 | 185 | Both | Right | ||||
| Neal Musser | Inactive | MLB | 1999-2010 | 8/25/1980 | Otterbein, Indiana | 6-2 | 209 | Left | Left | 1999 | 2 | 73 | NYM |
| Kurt Weigle | Retired | NCAA | 2002-2005 | 12/13/1982 | West Lafayette, Indiana | 6-2 | 225 | Right | Right | ||||
| Cy Williams | Deceased | MLB | 1912-1930 | 12/21/1887 | Wadena, Indiana | 6-2 | 180 | Left | Left | ||||