| List of Most Popular High Schools based on Alumni | Alumni Listed | |
| Puerto Rico Baseball Academy | Gurabo,PR | 99 |
| Lakewood | Lakewood,CA | 95 |
| Sarasota | Sarasota,FL | 93 |
| Columbus | Miami,FL | 86 |
| Bellaire | Bellaire,TX | 83 |
| Bellarmine Prep | San Jose,CA | 82 |
| Junipero Serra | San Mateo,CA | 82 |
| Mater Dei | Santa Ana,CA | 79 |
| Chatsworth | Chatsworth,CA | 71 |
| Jesuit | Tampa,FL | 71 |
| Chaparral | Scottsdale,AZ | 70 |
| Cherry Creek | Englewood,CO | 70 |
| Esperanza | Anaheim,CA | 70 |
| Moeller | Cincinnati,OH | 64 |
| Servite | Anaheim,CA | 62 |
| El Dorado | Placentia,CA | 61 |
| Bishop Amat | La Puente,CA | 61 |
| Hart | Newhall,CA | 59 |
| Tate | Cantonment,FL | 58 |
| Hillsborough | Tampa,FL | 58 |
| Bishop Gorman | Las Vegas,NV | 58 |
| Bullard | Fresno,CA | 56 |
| St. Thomas Aquinas | Fort Lauderdale,FL | 56 |
| De La Salle | Concord,CA | 56 |
| Poway | Poway,CA | 56 |
| Lake Brantley | Altamonte Springs,FL | 56 |
| Elk Grove | Elk Grove,CA | 56 |
| Los Alamitos | Los Alamitos,CA | 55 |
| Lassiter | Marietta,GA | 55 |
| Jesuit | New Orleans,LA | 55 |
| Calvert Hall | Baltimore,MD | 55 |
| Monsignor Pace | Miami,FL | 55 |
| The Woodlands | The Woodlands,TX | 55 |
| Columbus | Columbus,GA | 54 |
| Long Beach Poly | Long Beach,CA | 54 |
| St. Francis | Mountain View,CA | 53 |
| Southridge | Miami,FL | 53 |
| Millikan | Long Beach,CA | 52 |
| Santa Margarita Catholic | Rancho Santa Margarita,CA | 52 |
| Christian Brothers | Memphis,TN | 52 |
| Rancho Bernardo | San Diego,CA | 52 |
| Westlake | Westlake Village,CA | 52 |
| Killian | Miami,FL | 51 |
| Capistrano Valley | Mission Viejo,CA | 51 |
| Jesuit | Carmichael,CA | 50 |
| Mount Saint Joseph | Baltimore,MD | 50 |
| Grossmont | El Cajon,CA | 50 |
| Monte Vista | Danville,CA | 50 |
| El Camino Real | Woodland Hills,CA | 50 |
| Riverside Poly | Riverside,CA | 49 |
| Loyola | Los Angeles,CA | 49 |
| Westminster Christian | Miami,FL | 48 |
| Notre Dame | Sherman Oaks,CA | 48 |
| St. Ignatius | Cleveland,OH | 48 |
| Clovis West | Fresno,CA | 48 |
| Glendora | Glendora,CA | 47 |
| Arcadia | Arcadia,CA | 47 |
| Crespi Carmelite | Encino,CA | 47 |
| Green Valley | Henderson,NV | 46 |
| Barbe | Lake Charles,LA | 46 |
| Don Bosco Prep | Ramsey,NJ | 46 |
| Edison | Huntington Beach,CA | 46 |
| Lamar | Houston,TX | 46 |
| Archbishop Molloy | Jamaica,NY | 46 |
| Seton Hall Prep | West Orange,NJ | 46 |
| Wilson | Long Beach,CA | 45 |
| Marina | Huntington Beach,CA | 45 |
| Providence Catholic | New Lenox,IL | 45 |
| Walton | Marietta,GA | 45 |
| Riverview | Sarasota,FL | 45 |
| Newport | Bellevue,WA | 45 |
| Horizon | Scottsdale,AZ | 44 |
| Thousand Oaks | Thousand Oaks,CA | 44 |
| Gulliver Prep | Coral Gables,FL | 44 |
| Miami Senior | Miami,FL | 43 |
| Oviedo | Oviedo,FL | 43 |
| Dunedin | Dunedin,FL | 43 |
| Creighton Preparatory School | Omaha,NE | 43 |
| Palm Beach Gardens | Palm Beach Gardens,FL | 43 |
| Brophy College Prep | Phoenix,AZ | 43 |
| Carroll | Southlake,TX | 42 |
| Providence | Charlotte,NC | 42 |
| New Trier | Winnetka,IL | 42 |
| Fremont | Los Angeles,CA | 42 |
| South Hills | Covina,CA | 42 |
| Duncanville | Duncanville,TX | 42 |
| Fountain Valley | Fountain Valley,CA | 42 |
| Upland | Upland,CA | 42 |
| Granite Hills | El Cajon,CA | 42 |
| King | Tampa,FL | 41 |
| Chaminade | Mineola,NY | 41 |
| Torrey Pines | San Diego,CA | 41 |
| Martin | Arlington,TX | 41 |
| Mission Bay | San Diego,CA | 41 |
| Bishop Hendricken | Warwick,RI | 41 |
| Bishop Kenny | Jacksonville,FL | 41 |
| Berkeley | Berkeley,CA | 41 |
| The Bolles School | Jacksonville,FL | 41 |
| Archbishop Mitty | San Jose,CA | 40 |
| Parkview | Liburn,GA | 40 |