| Player | Team(s) | Current Status | Play Years | Awards |
| Brian Adams | Somerset | Inactive | 1997-2010 | All-Star LHP |
| Jay Caligiuri | Bridgeport | Retired | 2001-2009 | All-Star 3B |
| Ramon Castro | Newark | Inactive | 1997-2012 | All-Star SS |
| Javier Colina | Newark | Inactive | 1998-2012 | All-Star 2B |
| Derrick Depriest | Lancaster | Retired | 1997-2009 | All-Star RP |
| Steve Doetsch | Pennsylvania | Inactive | 2003-2012 | All-Star OF |
| Nate Espy | York | Retired | 1998-2007 | All-Star Utility |
| Carl Everett | Long Island | Inactive | 1990-2010 | All-Star OF |
| Danny Graves | Long Island | Retired | 1992-2008 | All-Star RP |
| Jesse Hoorelbeke | Bridgeport, Bridgeport | Inactive | 2001-2012 | All-Star 1B |
| Gary Knotts | Newark | Retired | 1995-2009 | All-Star RHP |
| Mike Lockwood | Somerset | Retired | 1997-2008 | All-Star OF |
| Randy McGarvey | Camden | Retired | 2000-2008 | All-Star C |
| Ray Navarrete | Long Island | Inactive | 1997-2012 | All-Star OF |
| Victor Rodriguez | Newark | Inactive | 1994-2010 | Player of the Year, All-Star DH |
| Pete Rose | Long Island | Manager - Great Falls (2013) | 1989-2009 | All-Star Utility |