| Player | Team(s) | Current Status | Play Years | Awards |
| Will Bashelor | Dartmouth | Retired | 2004-2006 | All-Star OF |
| Morgan Brown | Harvard, Harvard | Assistant Coach - Harvard University (2013) | 2003-2010 | All-Star SS |
| Paul Christian | Brown | Retired | 2003-2006 | All-Star OF |
| Adam Cole | Harvard, Harvard | Retired | 2006-2009 | Freshman of the Year |
| Steve Daniels | Brown, Brown | Retired | 2006-2009 | Freshman of the Year |
| Jeff Dietz | Brown, Brown | Inactive | 2005-2010 | All-Star Utility |
| Joshua Faiola | Dartmouth | Retired | 2003-2009 | All-Star P |
| Matt Fealey | Yale | Retired | 2004-2006 | All-Star RP |
| Shawn Haviland | Harvard | OAK Minors [AA] | 2005-2012 | Pitcher of the Year, All-Star P |
| Josh Klimkiewicz | Harvard | Retired | 2003-2006 | All-Star 1B |
| Dan Neczypor | Columbia University | Retired | 2005-2008 | All-Star DH |
| Marc Sawyer | Yale | Retired | 2004-2007 | All-Star 1B, Player of the Year |
| Bryan Tews | Brown, Brown | Retired | 2004-2007 | All-Star 2B |
| Devin Thomas | Brown | Retired | 2005-2009 | All-Star C |
| Matt Vance | Harvard | Retired | 2005-2008 | All-Star OF |
| Stephen Wendell | Princeton | Retired | 2003-2006 | All-Star DH |
| Steffan Wilson | Harvard, Harvard | Inactive | 2005-2011 | All-Star 3B |