| 2004 | NCAA | Freshman 1st team All-America SP | |
| | Pac10 | Pac-10 Freshman of the Year | |
| | Pac10 | Pac-10 Pitcher of the Year | |
| 2005 | Pac10 | Pac-10 Conference All-Star SP | |
| | Summer | Summer League First-Team All-American RP | |
| 2006 | NCAA | 1st Team College All-American SP | |
| | NCAA | Golden Spikes Award | |
| | Pac10 | Pacific 10 Conference All-Star SP | |
| | Pac10 | Pacific 10 Conference Pitcher of the Year | |
| 2008 | MLB | Major League 1st All-Star (end of season) SP | |
| | MLB-NL | National League Cy Young Award | |
| | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #23) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| | Team | San Francisco Giants Player of the Year | |
| 2009 | MLB | Major League 1st All-Star (end of season) SP | |
| | MLB-NL | National League Cy Young Award | |
| | MLB-NL | NL MVP (Voting Rank: #19) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| | Team | San Francisco Giants Player of the Year | |
| 2010 | MLB-NL | NL Cy Young Award (Voting Rank: # 11) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |
| 2011 | MLB-NL | NL Cy Young Award (Voting Rank: # 5) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (NL) | |