| 1993 | Sal | South Atlantic League All-Star SS | |
| 1994 | Minors | Baseball America 1st team Minor League All-Star SS | |
| | Team | Baseball America Minor League Player of the Year | |
| | Fsl | Florida State League All-Star SS | |
| | Fsl | Florida State League Most Valuable Player | |
| | Minors | Minor League Player of the Year | |
| | Team | New York Yankees Minor League Player of the Year | |
| 1995 | IL | International League All-Star SS | |
| 1996 | MLB-AL | American League Rookie of the Year | |
| 1997 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #24) | |
| 1998 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #3) | |
| | Team | New York Yankees Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 1999 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #6) | |
| | MLB | Baseball America First-Team Major League All-Star SS | |
| | Team | New York Yankees Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2000 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #10) | |
| | MLB | All-Star Game Most Valuable Player | |
| | Team | New York Yankees Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| | MLB | World Series Most Valuable Player | |
| 2001 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #10) | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2002 | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2003 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #21) | |
| 2004 | MLB-AL | AL Gold Glove Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #13) | |
| | MLB | Baseball America Second-Team Major League All-Star SS | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2005 | MLB-AL | AL Gold Glove Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #10) | |
| 2006 | MLB-AL | AL Gold Glove Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #2) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL Silver Slugger Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | American League Hank Aaron Award | |
| | Team | New York Yankees Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| | WBC | World Baseball Classic All-Star | |
| 2007 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #11) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL Silver Slugger Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2008 | MLB-AL | AL Silver Slugger Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2009 | MLB-AL | AL Gold Glove Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #3) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL Silver Slugger Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | American League Hank Aaron Award | |
| | MLB | Major League 2nd All-Star (end of season) SS | |
| | Team | New York Yankees Player of the Year | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| | MLB | Roberto Clemente Award | |
| 2010 | MLB-AL | AL Gold Glove Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2011 | MLB-AL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |
| 2012 | MLB-AL | AL MVP (Voting Rank: #7) | |
| | MLB-AL | AL Silver Slugger Award (SS) | |
| | MLB-NL | Played in MLB All-Star Game (AL) | |