Historical Winners - Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference Player of the Year | Top | Major Leaguers | Active Players | Drafted Players | 1st Round Draft Picks |
| Year | Player Name | Pos | Notes | C-Awards | Ht | Wt | B-T | BornDate | Age | Place | HiLvl | Stat Years | MLB Years | Draft Information | College(s) | Status | Current Org (Level) |
| 2018 | Greg Cullen | 2B | 2 | 5-10 | 190 | L-R | 1996-11-13 | 21 | Penfield,New York | RK | 2016-2018 | - | 2018-15- 442-ATL | Niagara U. | Minors | Atlanta Braves (Rk) | |
| 2017 | Jake Lumley | IF | 2 | 6-1 | 178 | L-R | 1995-02-13 | 22 | Windsor,Ontario | A | 2014-2018 | - | 2017-33- 981-OAK | Canisius Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2016 | Christian Santisteban | IF-OF | 3 | 6-2 | 205 | L-R | 1994-- | 22 | Miami,Florida | Ind | 2013-2016 | - | Manhattan Col | ||||
| 2015 | Brett Siddall | 1B-OF | 4 | 6-0 | 201 | L-L | 1994-10-03 | 20 | Windsor,Ontario | AA | 2013-2018 | - | 2015-13- 398-OAK | Canisius Col | Minors | Oakland Athletics (A+) | |
| 2014 | Connor Panas | 1B-3B | 4 | 5-11 | 204 | L-R | 1993-02-11 | 21 | Toronto,Ontario | AA | 2012-2018 | - | 2015- 9- 272-TOR | Canisius Col | Minors | Toronto Blue Jays (AA) | |
| 2013 | Mike Fish | OF | 2 | 5-11 | 170 | R-R | 1991-01-03 | 22 | Delmar,New York | AA | 2010-2016 | - | 2013-32- 967-ANA | Siena Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2012 | Chris Burke | 3B | 3 | 6-1 | 195 | R-R | 1990-04-26 | 22 | Islip,New York | AAA | 2009-2014 | - | 2012-18- 555-SDN | Iona Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2011 | Sean Jamieson | SS | 3 | 6-0 | 180 | R-R | 1989-03-02 | 22 | Simcoe,Ontario | AAA | 2010-2016 | - | 2011-17- 526-OAK | Canisius Col, Niagara County CC | Minors | Arizona Diamondbacks (AAA) | |
| 2011 | Dan Paolini | 1B-OF | 6 | 6-1 | 180 | R-R | 1989-10-11 | 21 | Stratford,Connecticut | AAA | 2009-2016 | - | 2011-10- 303-SEA | Siena Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2010 | Dan Paolini | 1B-OF | 6 | 6-1 | 180 | R-R | 1989-10-11 | 20 | Stratford,Connecticut | AAA | 2009-2016 | - | 2011-10- 303-SEA | Siena Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2009 | Kevin Mahoney | 3B | 3 | 6-0 | 210 | L-R | 1987-05-11 | 22 | Miller Place,New York | AAA | 2006-2014 | - | 2009-23- 705-NYA | Canisius Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2008 | Jacob Willis | 3B | 1 | 6-1 | 210 | R-R | 1986-- | 22 | Niantic,Connecticut | NCAA | 2005-2008 | - | Siena Col | ||||
| 2007 | Andy Parrino | SS | 3 | 6-0 | 185 | B-R | 1985-10-31 | 21 | Brockport,New York | MLB | 2005-2016 | 2011-2015 | 2007-26- 807-SDN | Le Moyne Col | Free Agent | ||
| 2006 | Mike Affronti | 3B | 3 | 6-1 | 190 | R-R | 1984-02-13 | 22 | Dix Hills,New York | AAA | 2003-2010 | - | 2006-17- 518-OAK | Le Moyne Col | |||
| 2005 | Matt Rizzotti | 1B | 7 | 6-5 | 235 | L-L | 1985-12-24 | 19 | Floral Park,New York | AAA | 2005-2012 | - | 2007- 6- 203-PHI | Borough Manhattan CC | Free Agent | ||
| 2004 | Jeff Justice | OF | 2 | 6-1 | 220 | R-R | 1981-05-31 | 23 | Woodbury,New Jersey | RK | 2001-2005 | - | Le Moyne Col | ||||
| 2003 | Josh McCurdy | OF | 2 | 6-6 | 215 | R-R | 1979-12-28 | 23 | Thornhill,Ontario | AAA | 1999-2006 | - | 2003-24- 704-BAL | Niagara U., Maine | |||
| 2002 | Anthony Bocchino | OF | 4 | 5-11 | 185 | L-L | 1980-05-15 | 22 | Brooklyn,New York | A+ | 1999-2005 | - | 2002-11- 313-PIT | Marist Col | |||
| 2001 | Ryan Finn | OF | 4 | 6-0 | 195 | R-R | 1980-01-04 | 21 | Clinton,New York | Ind | 1999-2002 | - | Siena Col | ||||
| 2000 | wil pikolycky | - | - |
