Historical Winners - Big East Conference Pitcher of the Year | Top | Major Leaguers | Active Players | Drafted Players | 1st Round Draft Picks |
| Year | Player Name | Pos | Notes | C-Awards | Ht | Wt | B-T | BornDate | Age | Place | HiLvl | Stat Years | MLB Years | Draft Information | College(s) | Status | Current Org (Level) |
| 2017 | Sean Mooney | P | 4 | 6-1 | 200 | R-R | 1998-- | 19 | Somers Point,New Jersey | NCAA | 2017-2018 | - | St. John's U. | ||||
| 2016 | Thomas Hackimer | P | 3 | 5-10 | 170 | R-R | 1994-06-28 | 22 | Floral Park,New York | A+ | 2013-2018 | - | 2016- 4- 123-MIN | St. John's U. | Minors | Minnesota Twins (A+) | |
| 2015 | Ryan McCormick | P | 2 | 6-2 | 200 | R-R | 1994-03-15 | 21 | Massapequa,New York | A | 2013-2016 | - | 2015-16- 467-COL | St. John's U. | Free Agent | ||
| 2014 | Josh Prevost | P | 3 | 6-8 | 220 | R-R | 1992-01-15 | 22 | Belle Mead,New Jersey | AAA | 2011-2018 | - | 2014- 5- 145-NYN | Seton Hall U. | DL-7 | New York Mets (AAA) | |
| 2013 | Jeff Thompson | P | 2 | 6-6 | 245 | R-R | 1991-09-23 | 21 | Louisville,Kentucky | AA | 2011-2018 | - | 2013- 3- 94-DET | Louisville | Minors | Detroit Tigers (A+) | |
| 2012 | Justin Amlung | P | 3 | 6-0 | 174 | R-R | 1990-05-21 | 22 | Louisville,Kentucky | A+ | 2010-2015 | - | 2012-12- 374-CHN | Louisville | Free Agent | ||
| 2011 | Matt Barnes | P | 6 | 6-3 | 180 | R-R | 1990-06-17 | 21 | Bethel,Connecticut | MLB | 2009-2018 | 2014-2018 | 2011- 1- 19-BOS | Connecticut | Active | Boston Red Sox (MLB) | |
| 2010 | Thomas Royse | P | 2 | 6-5 | 200 | R-R | 1988-09-07 | 21 | Lexington,Kentucky | RK | 2008-2012 | - | 2010- 3- 114-CHA | Louisville | Retired | ||
| 2009 | Justin Marks | P | 7 | 6-3 | 180 | L-L | 1988-01-12 | 21 | Owensboro,Kentucky | MLB | 2007-2017 | 2014-2017 | 2009- 3- 92-OAK | Louisville | Free Agent | ||
| 2008 | George Brown | P | 2 | 6-1 | 195 | L-L | 1986-06-18 | 22 | Boston,Massachusetts | A+ | 2005-2010 | - | 2008-27- 815-SLN | St. John's U. | |||
| 2007 | Zack Pitts | P | 2 | 6-3 | 195 | R-R | 1986-03-30 | 21 | Elizabethtown,Kentucky | A- | 2005-2009 | - | 2008-24- 725-SLN | Louisville | |||
| 2006 | Jeff Manship | P | 3 | 6-0 | 165 | R-R | 1985-01-16 | 21 | San Antonio,Texas | MLB | 2004-2016 | 2009-2016 | 2006-14- 426-MIN | Notre Dame | Free Agent | ||
| 2005 | Craig Hansen | P | 3 | 6-6 | 210 | R-R | 1983-11-15 | 21 | Glen Cove,New York | MLB | 2003-2012 | 2005-2009 | 2005- 1- 26-BOS | St. John's U. | Free Agent | ||
| 2004 | Chris Lambert | P | 7 | 6-1 | 205 | R-R | 1983-03-08 | 21 | Burlingame,California | MLB | 2003-2009 | 2008-2009 | 2004- 1- 19-SLN | Boston Col | |||
| 2004 | Nick Evangelista | P | 2 | 6-3 | 230 | R-R | 1982-03-17 | 22 | Reading,Pennsylvania | AA | 2001-2007 | - | 2004-26- 782-PHI | Pittsburgh, Louisburg Col | |||
| 2003 | Chris Niesel | P | 3 | 5-11 | 195 | R-R | 1982-11-18 | 20 | Fort Lauderdale,Florida | AAA | 2002-2007 | - | 2004- 9- 257-CLE | Notre Dame | |||
| 2002 | Chris Lambert | P | 7 | 6-1 | 205 | R-R | 1983-03-08 | 19 | Burlingame,California | MLB | 2003-2009 | 2008-2009 | 2004- 1- 19-SLN | Boston Col | |||
| 2001 | Aaron Heilman | P | 7 | 6-5 | 220 | R-R | 1978-11-12 | 22 | Logansport,Indiana | MLB | 1998-2012 | 2003-2011 | 2001- 1- 18-NYN | Notre Dame | Free Agent | ||
| 2000 | Aaron Heilman | P | 7 | 6-5 | 220 | R-R | 1978-11-12 | 21 | Logansport,Indiana | MLB | 1998-2012 | 2003-2011 | 2001- 1- 18-NYN | Notre Dame | Free Agent | ||
| 1999 | marc desroches | - | - | ||||||||||||||
| 1998 | Brad Lidge | P | 7 | 6-5 | 200 | R-R | 1976-12-23 | 21 | Sacramento,California | MLB | 1996-2012 | 2002-2012 | 1998- 1- 17-HOU | Notre Dame | Retired | ||
| 1997 | Chris Enochs | P | 3 | 6-3 | 225 | R-R | 1975-10-11 | 21 | Weirton,West Virginia | AAA | 1995-2005 | - | 1997- 1- 11-OAK | West Virginia U. | |||
| 1996 | Brian O'Hare | P | 1 | L-L | 1974-- | 22 | - | Ind | 1993-1996 | - | Georgetown U. | ||||||
| 1995 | Mike Macone | P | 2 | 5-10 | 175 | R-R | 1974-11-26 | 20 | Medford,Massachusetts | Ind | 1993-1999 | - | Providence Col | ||||
| 1994 | C.J. Nitkowski | P | 4 | 6-3 | 205 | L-L | 1973-03-09 | 21 | Suffern,New York | MLB | 1992-2012 | 1995-2005 | 1994- 1- 9-CIN | St. John's U., Florida Atl U. | Free Agent | ||
| 1993 | David Herr | P | 2 | 6-5 | 210 | R-R | 1973-07-07 | 19 | West Chester,Pennsylvania | A- | 1993-1995 | - | 1995-13- 367-MON | Villanova U. |
