| 2009 | NYY | PHI | 4-2 | NYY beat LAA 4-2 | PHI beat LAD 4-1 | NYY beat MIN 3-0, LAA beat BOS 3-0 | LAD beat STL 3-0, PHI beat COL 3-1 |
| 2008 | PHI | TB | 4-1 | TB beat BOS 4-3 | PHI beat LAD 4-1 | BOS beat LAA 3-1, TB beat CHW 3-1 | LAD beat CHC 3-0, PHI beat MIL 3-1 |
| 2007 | BOS | COL | 4-0 | BOS beat CLE 4-3 | COL beat ARI 4-0 | BOS beat LAA 3-0, CLE beat NYY 3-1 | ARI beat CHC 3-0, COL beat PHI 3-0 |
| 2006 | STL | DET | 4-1 | DET beat OAK 4-0 | STL beat NYM 4-3 | DET beat NYY 3-1, OAK beat MIN 3-0 | NYM beat LAD 3-0, STL beat SD 3-1 |
| 2005 | CHW | HOU | 4-0 | CHW beat LAA 4-1 | HOU beat STL 4-2 | CHW beat BOS 3-0, LAA beat NYY 3-2 | STL beat SD 3-0, HOU beat ATL 3-1 |
| 2004 | BOS | STL | 4-0 | BOS beat NYY 4-3 | STL beat HOU 4-3 | BOS beat LAA 3-0, NYY beat MIN 3-1 | STL beat LAD 3-1, HOU beat ATL 3-2 |