| |
|
| Player Name | Born Date | Pos | High Level | MLB Years | Last Active | High School | College |
| |
| Paddy Baumann | 12/20/1885 | 2B-3B | MLB | 1911-1917 | 1917 | | |
| Tim Bogar | 10/28/1966 | SS-3B | MLB | 1993-2001 | 2002 | Buffalo Grove (Buffalo Grove,IL) | Eastern Illinois University |
| Donie Bush | 10/8/1887 | SS | MLB | 1908-1923 | 1923 | | |
| Rich Coggins | 12/7/1950 | OF | MLB | 1972-1976 | 1976 | Garey (Pomona,CA) | |
| Roy Corhan | 10/21/1887 | SS | MLB | 1911-1916 | 1916 | | |
| Carl Dale | 12/7/1972 | P | MLB | 1999-1999 | 2003 | Cookeville (Cookeville,TN) | Winthrop University |
| Hooks Dauss | 9/22/1889 | P | MLB | 1912-1926 | 1926 | | |
| Charlie French | 10/12/1883 | 2B-SS | MLB | 1909-1910 | 1910 | | |
| Oral Hildebrand | 4/7/1907 | P | MLB | 1931-1940 | 1940 | | |
| Jeff James | 9/29/1941 | P | MLB | 1968-1969 | 1969 | | Indiana State University |
| Ron Keller | 6/3/1943 | P | MLB | 1966-1968 | 1968 | | Indiana University |
| Matt Kinzer | 6/17/1963 | P | MLB | 1989-1990 | 1990 | | Purdue University |
| Chuck Klein | 10/7/1904 | OF | MLB | 1928-1944 | 1944 | | |
| Don Leppert | 10/19/1931 | C | MLB | 1961-1964 | 1964 | | |
| Joe McCabe | 8/27/1938 | C | MLB | 1964-1965 | 1965 | | Purdue University |
| Kent Mercker | 2/1/1968 | P | MLB | 1989-2006 | 2006 | Dublin (Dublin,OH) | |
| Don Miles | 3/13/1936 | OF | MLB | 1958-1958 | 1958 | | |
| Dennis Musgraves | 12/25/1943 | P | MLB | 1965-1965 | 1965 | | University of Missouri |
| Doc Newton | 10/26/1877 | P | MLB | 1905-1909 | 1909 | | |
| Ray Oyler | 8/4/1938 | SS | MLB | 1965-1970 | 1970 | | |
| Jeff Parrett | 8/26/1961 | P | MLB | 1986-1996 | 1996 | | University of Kentucky |
| Rodney Scott | 10/16/1953 | 2B-SS | MLB | 1975-1982 | 1983 | Arlington (Indianapolis,IN) | |
| Steve Senteney | 8/7/1955 | P | MLB | 1982-1982 | 1985 | | |
| Joe Slusarski | 12/19/1966 | P | MLB | 1991-2001 | 2001 | Sacred Heart-Griffin (Springfield,IL) | University of New Orleans |
| Joe Thatcher | 4/10/1981 | P | MLB | 2007-2007 | 2007 | | Indiana State University |
| Gary Thurman | 11/12/1964 | RF-LF | MLB | 1987-1997 | 1998 | North Central (Indianapolis,IN) | |
| Bill Whaley | 2/10/1899 | OF | MLB | 1923-1923 | 1923 | | |
| |
| |
|
| Player Name | Born Date | Pos | High Level | MLB Years | Last Active | High School | College |
| |
| Sean Bogle | 10/3/1973 | P | AA | | 1997 | | Indiana State University |
| Joe Buckley | 4/14/1966 | P | A- | | 1989 | Northgate (Walnut Creek,CA) | University of California |
| Jordan Cheatham | 11/2/1987 | OF | Rookie | | 2007 | Pike (Indianapolis,IN) | Wabash Valley College |
| Sherard Clinkscales | 4/15/1970 | P | A | | 1994 | | Purdue University |
| Jon DeClue | 9/17/1970 | | AA | | 1997 | Apopka (Apopka,FL) | Florida Southern College |
| Tim Dell | 4/8/1967 | P | AA | | 1993 | | Huntington College (Ind.) |
| Chris Estep | 10/23/1966 | OF | AA | | 1992 | | University of Kentucky |
| David Gandolph | 3/20/1970 | P | AA | | 1995 | | Indiana University |
| Jon Graves | 8/5/1971 | P | Rookie | | 1995 | | Long Beach State University |
| Brian Harris | 4/28/1975 | 2B | AAA | | 2003 | Carmel (Carmel,IN) | Indiana University |
| Damien Hart | 6/24/1975 | P | A | | 1999 | | Coastal Carolina University |
| Joe Hicks | | 1B | AAA | | 1986 | John Marshall (Indianapolis,IN) | Florida State University |
| Scott Hilinski | 12/10/1979 | IF | A | | 2003 | | Warner Southern College (Fla.) |
| Todd Hobson | 3/9/1970 | OF/DH | A | | 1993 | Lawrence North (Indianapolis,IN) | Indiana State University |
| Thomas Johnston | 2/28/1973 | SS | A- | | 1994 | | |
| Josh Khoury | 5/20/1978 | P | A- | | 2001 | | Jacksonville University |
| John Kremer | 11/19/1976 | P | AA | | 2003 | | University of Evansville |
| John Lamar | 5/29/1970 | OF/DH | A+ | | 1994 | Decatur Central (Indianapolis,IN) | Indiana State University |
| Chris Maffett | 1/22/1973 | P | A- | | 1992 | Southport (Indianapolis,IN) | |
| Jason Quarles | 4/20/1983 | P | A | | 2005 | | Southern University |
| Eric Riggs | 8/19/1976 | P | AAA | | 2007 | | University of Central Florida |
| Jon Skorupski | 7/13/1983 | 1B | A- | | 2005 | | University of Florida |
| John Trisler | 3/19/1970 | P | AA | | 1995 | | Indiana State University |
| Justin Turner | 12/19/1979 | IF | AA | | 2005 | | Warner Southern College (Fla.) |
| Corey Wade | 5/28/1983 | P | AA | | 2007 | Broad Ripple (Indianapolis,IN) | Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| Wes Whisler | 4/7/1983 | P | AA | | 2007 | | UCLA |
| A.J. Zapp | 4/24/1978 | 1B | AAA | | 2006 | Center Grove (Greenwood,IN) | |
| |
| |
| College and other players |
|
| Player Name | Born Date | Pos | High Level | MLB Years | Last Active | High School | College |
| |
| Mark Adkins | 12/31/1984 | OF | College | | 2005 | Carmel (Carmel,IN) | Samford University |
| Jay Brant | 9/21/1982 | IF | College | | 2006 | Brebeuf Jesuit (Indianapolis,IN) | Indiana University |
| Jay Broughton | 11/10/1986 | P | College | | 2007 | Triton Central (Indianapolis,IN) | Ball State University |
| Stephen Bryant | 10/4/1983 | C | - | | 0 | Warren Central (Indianapolis,IN) | |
| Cory Dragstrem | 5/27/1987 | IF | College | | 2007 | Brownsburg (Brownsburg,IN) | Ball State University |
| Scott Headd | 10/21/1982 | C | College | | 2005 | Dulaney (Timonium,MD) | University of Virginia |
| Eric Montross | 9/23/1971 | P | - | | 0 | Lawrence (Indianapolis,IN) | University of North Carolina |
| Mike Shebek | 12/13/1965 | P | - | | 0 | North Central (Indianapolis,IN) | Ball State University |
| Drew Storen | 8/11/1987 | P | - | | 0 | Brownsburg (Brownsburg,IN) | Stanford University |
| |