| 1995 | Bowman | R | 22 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1996 | Bowman | Best | 100 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1996 | Bowman | R | 312 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1996 | Topps | R | 428 | Bartolo Colon, Doug Million, Ray Ricken, Rafael Orellano Prospects | |
| 1997 | Bowman | Best | 111 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Bowman | Chrome | 118 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Bowman | R | 94 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Donruss | R | 354 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Donruss | Studio | 159 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Fleer | Ultra | 550 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Fleer | Update | 561 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Leaf | R | 326 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Pinnacle | Totally Certified | 131 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | SP | R | 8 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Topps | R | 386 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Topps | Stadium Club | 192 | Bartolo Colon 2000 | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Topps | Stadium Club Millennium | 24 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Upper Deck | Collectors Choice | 464 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Upper Deck | R | 529 | Bartolo Colon Trade | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Donruss | Elite | 92 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Donruss | R | 109 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Donruss | Signature | 117 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Donruss | Studio | 121 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Fleer | Tradition | 155 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Leaf | Fractual Foundation | 88 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Leaf | R | 88 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Leaf | Rookies and Stars | 266 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Pinnacle | Performers | 108 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Score | Rookies and Traded | 63 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Topps | Finest | 212 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Topps | R | 360 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1998 | Upper Deck | R | 75 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Bowman | R | 255 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Fleer | Tradition | 56 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Fleer | Ultra | 15 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Pacific | Crown Collection | 83 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Pacific | Paramount | 71 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Pacific | Prism | 42 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Pacific | R | 125 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Skybox | Premium | 207 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | SP | Signature | 114 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Topps | Finest | 66 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Topps | Gallery | 125 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Topps | R | 40 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Topps | Stadium Club | 17 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Upper Deck | R | 78 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 1999 | Upper Deck | R | 237 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Bowman | R | 38 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Fleer | Greats of the Game | 199 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Fleer | Tradition | 259 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Pacific | Crown Collection | 76 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Pacific | Invincible Diamond Aces | 8 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Pacific | Prism | 42 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Pacific | R | 128 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Skybox | Dominion | 177 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | SkyBox | R | 157 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Topps | Finest | 47 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Topps | Gold Label | 126 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Topps | R | 366 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Upper Deck | MVP | 98 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Upper Deck | R | 366 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2000 | Upper Deck | Victory | 149 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Bowman | Best | 93 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Bowman | Heritage | 5 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Bowman | R | 59 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Donruss | Classics | 61 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Donruss | R | 83 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Donruss | Signatures | 61 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Donruss | Studio | 61 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Fleer | Authority | 93 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Fleer | Platinum | 205 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Fleer | Tradition | 410 | Bartolo Colon AL ERA Leaders | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Fleer | Tradition | 78 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Fleer | Ultra | 63 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Leaf | Certified Materials | 61 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Leaf | Limited | 6 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Leaf | Rookies and Stars | 39 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Pacific | R | 124 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Topps | Gallery | 5 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Topps | Heritage | 88 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Topps | Opening Day | 78 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Topps | R | 245 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | MVP | 46 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | R | 75 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | Reserve | 23 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | Victory | 81 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | Victory | 91 | Manny Ramirez, Bartolo Colon Checklist | Cleveland Indians |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | Vintage | 397 | Mike Sirotka, Pedro Martinez, Roger Clemens, Mike Mussina, Bartolo Colon AL ERA Leaders | |
| 2001 | Upper Deck | Vintage | 48 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Bowman | Best | 40 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Bowman | Heritage | 259 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Bowman | R | 37 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Donruss | Diamond Kings | 24 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Donruss | Elite | 51 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Donruss | Fan Club | 165 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Donruss | Originals | 344 | Bartolo Colon 1986 | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Donruss | Originals | 223 | Bartolo Colon 1984 | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Donruss | Originals | 60 | Bartolo Colon 1982 | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Donruss | R | 68 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Donruss | Studio | 71 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Fleer | Box Score International | 229 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Fleer | Genuine | 46 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Fleer | Maximum | 147 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Fleer | Platinum | 152 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Fleer | Tradition | 160 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Fleer | Tradition Update | 217 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Fleer | Ultra | 63 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Leaf | Certified | 19 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Leaf | R | 64 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Leaf | Rookies and Stars | 198 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Topps | 206 | 53 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | 206 | 357 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Topps | Gallery | 128 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | Gold Label | 110 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | Heritage | 354 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | Opening Day | 89 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | R | 252 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | Total | 223 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Topps | Traded | 14 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2002 | Upper Deck | 40 Man | 1151 | Bartolo Colon Rotation | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Upper Deck | 40 Man | 140 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Upper Deck | MVP | 47 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Upper Deck | R | 108 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Upper Deck | Victory | 81 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2002 | Upper Deck | Vintage | 38 | Bartolo Colon | Cleveland Indians |
| 2003 | Bowman | Chrome | 16 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Bowman | Heritage | 107 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Bowman | R | 16 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Donruss | Diamond Kings | 120 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Donruss | Elite | 128 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Donruss | R | 328 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Donruss | Signature | 21 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Donruss | Studio | 22 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Donruss | Team Heroes | 312 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Fleer | Authentix | 98 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Fleer | Box Score | 70 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Fleer | Box Score International R | 189 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Fleer | Genuine | 63 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Fleer | Hardball | 155 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Fleer | Showcase | 10 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Fleer | Splendid Splinters | 7 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Fleer | Tradition | 40 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Fleer | Tradition Update | 106 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Leaf | R | 196 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | SP | Authentic | 37 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | SPx | R | 31 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Topps | Chrome | 361 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Topps | Finest | 55 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Topps | Gallery | 46 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Topps | Heritage | 263 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Topps | Opening Day | 18 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Topps | Pristine | 47 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Topps | R | 546 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Topps | Total | 529 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | 40 Man | 323 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Classic Portraits | 39 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Finite | 28 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | First Pitch | 195 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | First Pitch | 286 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Game Face | 66 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Honor Roll | 114 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Honor Roll | 113 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | MVP | 119 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | R | 195 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | R | 362 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Vintage | 88 | Bartolo Colon | Montreal Expos |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Vintage | 237 | Bartolo Colon, Randy Johnson, A.J. Burnett Stellar Stat Men | |
| 2003 | Upper Deck | Vintage Update | 302 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Bazooka | R | 114 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Bowman | R | 22 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Donruss | Elite | 5 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Donruss | Leather and Lumber | 1 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Donruss | R | 98 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Donruss | Studio | 1 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Donruss | Team Heroes | 441 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Donruss | ThrowBack Threads | 1 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Donruss | World Series | 1 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Fleer | InScribed | 2 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Fleer | Patchworks | 74 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Fleer | Platinum | 81 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Fleer | Tradition | 74 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Fleer | Ultra | 5 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Fleer | Ultra Update | 240 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Leaf | Certified Cuts | 4 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Leaf | Limited | 14 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Leaf | R | 19 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | SP | Authentic | 7 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Topps | Chrome | 8 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Topps | Finest | 77 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Topps | Heritage | 463 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Topps | Heritage Chrome | 24 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Topps | Opening Day | 86 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Topps | R | 215 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2004 | Topps | Total | 595 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Topps | Traded | 30 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Upper Deck | Play Ball | 106 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Upper Deck | Power Up | 42 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Upper Deck | R | 272 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Upper Deck | Reflections | 9 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2004 | Upper Deck | Vintage | 37 | Bartolo Colon | Chicago White Sox |
| 2005 | Bazooka | R | 29 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Bowman | Heritage | 81 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Bowman | R | 85 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Donruss | Elite | 1 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Donruss | Leather and Lumber | 14 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Donruss | R | 71 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Donruss | Team Heroes | 2 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Donruss | Throwback Threads | 196 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Fleer | Tradition | 18 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Fleer | Tradition | 3 | Bartolo Colon, Curt Schilling, Johan Santana AL Win Leaders | |
| 2005 | Fleer | Ultra | 78 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Leaf | Limited | 129 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Leaf | R | 1 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Chrome | 72 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Cracker Jack | 174 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Finest | 13 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Gallery | 12 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Heritage | 113 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Opening Day | 52 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Pack Wars | 8 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | R | 231 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Total | 107 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Topps | Update | 138 | Bartolo Colon, Jon Garland, Cliff Lee AL Win Leaders | |
| 2005 | Topps | Update | 171 | Bartolo Colon All-Star | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Upper Deck | First Pitch | 321 | Bartolo Colon, Bengie Molina SOD | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Upper Deck | R | 301 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2005 | Zenith | R | 85 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim |
| 2006 | Bazooka | R | 122 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Bowman | Heritage | 91 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Bowman | R | 195 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Fleer | Flair Showcase | 97 | Bartolo Colon Upper Deck | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Fleer | R | 2 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Fleer | Tradition | 15 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Fleer | Ultra | 2 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | SPx | R | 45 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | Chrome | 135 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | Chrome | 270 | Bartolo Colon Award Winner | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | Co-Signers | 96 | Bartolo Colon | teamName |
| 2006 | Topps | Finest | 60 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | Heritage | 169 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | Opening Day | 57 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | R | 260 | Bartolo Colon Cy Young | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | R | 224 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Topps | Triple Threads | 59 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Upper Deck | Epic | 272 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Upper Deck | First Pitch | 214 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Upper Deck | Ovation | 2 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Upper Deck | R | 2 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Upper Deck | Sweet Spot | 1 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2006 | Upper Deck | Sweet Spot Update | 45 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2007 | Bowman | Heritage | 54 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2007 | Fleer | R | 179 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2007 | Fleer | Ultra | 90 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2007 | Topps | Chrome | 222 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2007 | Upper Deck | First Edition | 108 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2007 | Upper Deck | R | 146 | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels |
| 2008 | Topps | Update | 14 | Bartolo Colon | Boston Red Sox |