| 1936 | Ty Cobb ((222 votes - 98.23%)), Walter Johnson ((189 votes - 83.63%)), Christy Mathewson ((205 votes - 90.71%)), Babe Ruth ((215 votes - 95.13%)), Honus Wagner ((215 votes - 95.13%)) |
| 1937 | Morgan Bulkeley (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Ban Johnson (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Nap Lajoie ((168 votes - 83.58%)), Connie Mack (by Veterans Committee as Manager), John McGraw (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Tris Speaker ((165 votes - 82.09%)), George Wright (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Cy Young ((153 votes - 76.12%)) |
| 1938 | Pete Alexander ((212 votes - 80.92%)), Alexander Cartwright (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Henry Chadwick (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1939 | Cap Anson (by Veterans Committee as Player), Eddie Collins ((213 votes - 77.74%)), Charlie Comiskey (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Candy Cummings (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Buck Ewing (by Veterans Committee as Player), Willie Keeler ((207 votes - 75.55%)), Charley Radbourn (by Veterans Committee as Player), George Sisler ((235 votes - 85.77%)), Al Spalding (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1942 | Rogers Hornsby ((182 votes - 78.11%)) |
| 1944 | Kenesaw Landis (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1945 | Roger Bresnahan (by Veterans Committee as Player), Dan Brouthers (by Veterans Committee as Player), Fred Clarke (by Veterans Committee as Player), Jimmy Collins (by Veterans Committee as Player), Ed Delahanty (by Veterans Committee as Player), Hugh Duffy (by Veterans Committee as Player), Hughie Jennings (by Veterans Committee as Player), King Kelly (by Veterans Committee as Player), Jim O'Rourke (by Veterans Committee as Player), Wilbert Robinson (by Veterans Committee as Manager) |
| 1946 | Jesse Burkett (by Veterans Committee as Player), Frank Chance (by Veterans Committee as Player), Jack Chesbro (by Veterans Committee as Player), Johnny Evers (by Veterans Committee as Player), Clark Griffith (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Tommy McCarthy (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe McGinnity (by Veterans Committee as Player), Eddie Plank (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe Tinker (by Veterans Committee as Player), Rube Waddell (by Veterans Committee as Player), Ed Walsh (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1947 | Mickey Cochrane ((128 votes - 79.5%)), Frankie Frisch ((136 votes - 84.47%)), Lefty Grove ((123 votes - 76.4%)), Carl Hubbell ((140 votes - 86.96%)) |
| 1948 | Herb Pennock ((94 votes - 77.69%)), Pie Traynor ((93 votes - 76.86%)) |
| 1949 | Mordecai Brown (by Veterans Committee as Player), Charlie Gehringer ((159 votes - 85.03%)), Kid Nichols (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1951 | Jimmie Foxx ((179 votes - 79.2%)), Mel Ott ((197 votes - 87.17%)) |
| 1952 | Harry Heilmann ((203 votes - 86.75%)), Paul Waner ((195 votes - 83.33%)) |
| 1953 | Ed Barrow (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Chief Bender (by Veterans Committee as Player), Tom Connolly (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Dizzy Dean ((209 votes - 79.17%)), Bill Klem (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Al Simmons ((199 votes - 75.38%)), Bobby Wallace (by Veterans Committee as Player), Harry Wright (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1954 | Bill Dickey ((202 votes - 80.16%)), Rabbit Maranville ((209 votes - 82.94%)), Bill Terry ((195 votes - 77.38%)) |
| 1955 | Frank Baker (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe DiMaggio ((223 votes - 88.84%)), Gabby Hartnett ((195 votes - 77.69%)), Ted Lyons ((217 votes - 86.45%)), Ray Schalk (by Veterans Committee as Player), Dazzy Vance ((205 votes - 81.67%)) |
| 1956 | Joe Cronin ((152 votes - 78.76%)), Hank Greenberg ((164 votes - 84.97%)) |
| 1957 | Sam Crawford (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe McCarthy (by Veterans Committee as Manager) |
| 1959 | Zack Wheat (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1961 | Max Carey (by Veterans Committee as Player), Billy Hamilton (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1962 | Bob Feller ((150 votes - 93.75%)), Bill McKechnie (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Jackie Robinson ((124 votes - 77.5%)), Edd Roush (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1963 | John Clarkson (by Veterans Committee as Player), Elmer Flick (by Veterans Committee as Player), Sam Rice (by Veterans Committee as Player), Eppa Rixey (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1964 | Luke Appling ((189 votes - 84%)), Red Faber (by Veterans Committee as Player), Burleigh Grimes (by Veterans Committee as Player), Miller Huggins (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Tim Keefe (by Veterans Committee as Player), Heinie Manush (by Veterans Committee as Player), John Ward (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1965 | Pud Galvin (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1966 | Casey Stengel (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Ted Williams ((282 votes - 93.38%)) |
| 1967 | Branch Rickey (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Red Ruffing ((266 votes - 86.93%)), Lloyd Waner (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1968 | Kiki Cuyler (by Veterans Committee as Player), Goose Goslin (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe Medwick ((240 votes - 84.81%)) |
| 1969 | Roy Campanella ((270 votes - 79.41%)), Stan Coveleski (by Veterans Committee as Player), Waite Hoyt (by Veterans Committee as Player), Stan Musial ((317 votes - 93.24%)) |
| 1970 | Lou Boudreau ((232 votes - 77.33%)), Earle Combs (by Veterans Committee as Player), Ford Frick (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Jesse Haines (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1971 | Dave Bancroft (by Veterans Committee as Player), Jake Beckley (by Veterans Committee as Player), Chick Hafey (by Veterans Committee as Player), Harry Hooper (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe Kelley (by Veterans Committee as Player), Rube Marquard (by Veterans Committee as Player), George Weiss (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1972 | Yogi Berra ((339 votes - 85.61%)), Lefty Gomez (by Veterans Committee as Player), Will Harridge (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Sandy Koufax ((344 votes - 86.87%)), Early Wynn ((301 votes - 76.01%)), Ross Youngs (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1973 | Billy Evans (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), George Kelly (by Veterans Committee as Player), Warren Spahn ((316 votes - 83.16%)), Mickey Welch (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1974 | Jim Bottomley (by Veterans Committee as Player), Jocko Conlan (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Whitey Ford ((284 votes - 77.81%)), Mickey Mantle ((322 votes - 88.22%)), Sam Thompson (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1975 | Earl Averill (by Veterans Committee as Player), Bucky Harris (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Billy Herman (by Veterans Committee as Player), Ralph Kiner ((273 votes - 75.41%)) |
| 1976 | Roger Connor (by Veterans Committee as Player), Cal Hubbard (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Bob Lemon ((305 votes - 78.61%)), Freddie Lindstrom (by Veterans Committee as Player), Robin Roberts ((337 votes - 86.86%)) |
| 1977 | Ernie Banks ((321 votes - 83.81%)), Al Lopez (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Amos Rusie (by Veterans Committee as Player), Joe Sewell (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1978 | Addie Joss (by Veterans Committee as Player), Larry MacPhail (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Eddie Mathews ((301 votes - 79.42%)) |
| 1979 | Warren Giles (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Willie Mays ((409 votes - 94.68%)), Hack Wilson (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1980 | Al Kaline ((340 votes - 88.31%)), Chuck Klein (by Veterans Committee as Player), Duke Snider ((333 votes - 86.49%)), Tom Yawkey (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1981 | Rube Foster (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Bob Gibson ((337 votes - 84.04%)), Johnny Mize (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1982 | Hank Aaron ((406 votes - 97.83%)), Happy Chandler (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Travis Jackson (by Veterans Committee as Player), Frank Robinson ((370 votes - 89.16%)) |
| 1983 | Walter Alston (by Veterans Committee as Manager), George Kell (by Veterans Committee as Player), Juan Marichal ((313 votes - 83.69%)), Brooks Robinson ((344 votes - 91.98%)) |
| 1984 | Luis Aparicio ((341 votes - 84.62%)), Don Drysdale ((316 votes - 78.41%)), Rick Ferrell (by Veterans Committee as Player), Harmon Killebrew ((335 votes - 83.13%)), Pee Wee Reese (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1985 | Lou Brock ((315 votes - 79.75%)), Enos Slaughter (by Veterans Committee as Player), Arky Vaughan (by Veterans Committee as Player), Hoyt Wilhelm ((331 votes - 83.8%)) |
| 1986 | Bobby Doerr (by Veterans Committee as Player), Ernie Lombardi (by Veterans Committee as Player), Willie McCovey ((346 votes - 81.41%)) |
| 1987 | Ray Dandridge (by Veterans Committee as Player), Catfish Hunter ((315 votes - 76.27%)), Billy Williams ((354 votes - 85.71%)) |
| 1988 | Willie Stargell ((352 votes - 82.44%)) |
| 1989 | Al Barlick (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Johnny Bench ((431 votes - 96.42%)), Red Schoendienst (by Veterans Committee as Player), Carl Yastrzemski ((423 votes - 94.63%)) |
| 1990 | Joe Morgan ((363 votes - 81.76%)), Jim Palmer ((411 votes - 92.57%)) |
| 1991 | Rod Carew ((401 votes - 90.52%)), Fergie Jenkins ((334 votes - 75.4%)), Tony Lazzeri (by Veterans Committee as Player), Gaylord Perry ((342 votes - 77.2%)), Bill Veeck (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive) |
| 1992 | Rollie Fingers ((349 votes - 81.16%)), Bill McGowan (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Hal Newhouser (by Veterans Committee as Player), Tom Seaver ((425 votes - 98.84%)) |
| 1993 | Reggie Jackson ((396 votes - 93.62%)) |
| 1994 | Steve Carlton ((436 votes - 95.61%)), Leo Durocher (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Phil Rizzuto (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1995 | Richie Ashburn (by Veterans Committee as Player), Leon Day (by Veterans Committee as Player), William Hulbert (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Mike Schmidt ((444 votes - 96.52%)), Vic Willis (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1996 | Jim Bunning (by Veterans Committee as Player), Bill Foster (by Veterans Committee as Player), Ned Hanlon (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Earl Weaver (by Veterans Committee as Manager) |
| 1997 | Nellie Fox (by Veterans Committee as Player), Tom Lasorda (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Phil Niekro ((380 votes - 80.34%)), Willie Wells (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 1998 | George Davis (by Veterans Committee as Player), Larry Doby (by Veterans Committee as Player), Lee MacPhail (by Veterans Committee as Pioneer/Executive), Bullet Rogan (by Veterans Committee as Player), Don Sutton ((386 votes - 81.61%)) |
| 1999 | George Brett ((488 votes - 98.19%)), Orlando Cepeda (by Veterans Committee as Player), Nestor Chylak (by Veterans Committee as Umpire), Nolan Ryan ((491 votes - 98.79%)), Frank Selee (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Joe Williams (by Veterans Committee as Player), Robin Yount ((385 votes - 77.46%)) |
| 2000 | Sparky Anderson (by Veterans Committee as Manager), Carlton Fisk ((397 votes - 79.56%)), Bid McPhee (by Veterans Committee as Player), Tony Perez ((385 votes - 77.15%)), Turkey Stearnes (by Veterans Committee as Player) |
| 2001 | Bill Mazeroski (by Veterans Committee as Player), Kirby Puckett ((423 votes - 82.14%)), Hilton Smith (by Veterans Committee as Player), Dave Winfield ((435 votes - 84.47%)) |
| 2002 | Ozzie Smith ((433 votes - 91.74%)) |
| 2003 | Gary Carter ((387 votes - 78.02%)), Eddie Murray ((423 votes - 85.28%)) |
| 2004 | Dennis Eckersley ((421 votes - 83.2%)), Paul Molitor ((431 votes - 85.18%)) |
| 2005 | Wade Boggs ((474 votes - 91.9%)), Ryne Sandberg ((393 votes - 76.2%)) |
| 2006 | Bruce Sutter ((400 votes - 76.9%)), Bruce Sutter ((400 votes - 76.9%)) |
| 2007 | Tony Gwynn ((532 votes - 97.6%)), Cal Ripken ((537 votes - 98.5%)) |
| 2008 | Rich Gossage ((466 votes - 85.8%)) |
| 2009 | Rickey Henderson ((511 votes - 94.8%)), Jim Rice ((412 votes - 76.4%)) |
