Home » Events » Awards » Cy Young Award

» Cy Young Award | History

This page includes history for this award between 1956-2008

Most Recent Winner(s) (2008): Ryan Dempster (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Brad Lidge (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Daisuke Matsuzaka (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Francisco Rodriguez (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), C.C. Sabathia (NL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Ervin Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Johan Santana (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Brandon Webb (NL (Voting Rank: # 2))

2009 Independent League Statistics have been updated.

TBC Twitter Page - For Site Updates

The Football Cube

Centerfield Wall Ad Zone

Pricing Baseball Cards - Baseball Card Grading at Wholesale prices. Grade for as low as $2.00 a card.

Other Advertisers: MLB Trade Rumors Baseball Equipment Baseball Bargains Pro Fantasy Baseball Baseball Slant Forums Fantasy Ethos

Cy Young Award

Year	Award Winners
1956	Whitey Ford (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Sal Maglie (Major League (Voting Rank: #2)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #3))
1957	Dick Donovan (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1958	Lew Burdette (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Bob Friend (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1959	Sam Jones (Major League (Voting Rank: #2)), Bob Shaw (Major League (Voting Rank: #3))
1960	Ernie Broglio (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Lindy McDaniel (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1961	Frank Lary (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1962	Billy Pierce (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Bob Purkey (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Jack Sanford (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1964	Larry Jackson (Major League (Voting Rank: #2)), Sandy Koufax (Major League (Voting Rank: #3))
1967	Jim Bunning (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Joel Horlen (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fergie Jenkins (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
1969	Dave McNally (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Perry (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1970	Mike Cuellar (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dave Giusti (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Wayne Granger (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Fergie Jenkins (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Sam McDowell (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dave McNally (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Merritt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Carl Morton (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Gary Nolan (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Ron Perranoski (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Gaylord Perry (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Luke Walker (NL (Voting Rank: #10)), Clyde Wright (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
1971	Al Downing (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dick Drago (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dock Ellis (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bob Gibson (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jerry Johnson (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mickey Lolich (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Juan Marichal (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Dave McNally (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Messersmith (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Roberts (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bill Stoneman (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Wilbur Wood (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1972	Steve Blass (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Clay Carroll (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bob Gibson (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Catfish Hunter (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Fergie Jenkins (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mickey Lolich (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Sparky Lyle (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Marshall (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Gary Nolan (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Milt Pappas (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Luis Tiant (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Wilbur Wood (AL (Voting Rank: #2))
1973	Jack Billingham (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Vida Blue (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Ron Bryant (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jim Colborn (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dave Giusti (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), John Hiller (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Catfish Hunter (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Marshall (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fred Norman (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Gaylord Perry (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Wilbur Wood (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1974	Jack Billingham (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Buzz Capra (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Clay Carroll (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Mike Cuellar (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dave Giusti (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Don Gullett (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), John Hiller (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Al Hrabosky (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Fergie Jenkins (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Lynn McGlothen (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Andy Messersmith (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Gaylord Perry (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Luis Tiant (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
1975	Vida Blue (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Rollie Fingers (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Don Gullett (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Al Hrabosky (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Catfish Hunter (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Randy Jones (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Kaat (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Messersmith (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), John Montefusco (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Frank Tanana (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rick Wise (AL (Voting Rank: #8))
1976	Vida Blue (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Bill Campbell (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Steve Carlton (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rawly Eastwick (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mark Fidrych (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Ed Figueroa (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rollie Fingers (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Wayne Garland (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Jerry Koosman (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jon Matlack (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), J.R. Richard (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Frank Tanana (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Luis Tiant (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1977	Bill Campbell (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), John Candelaria (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Goltz (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Tommy John (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dennis Leonard (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Rick Reuschel (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dave Rozema (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Frank Tanana (AL (Voting Rank: #9))
1978	Vida Blue (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Caldwell (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ed Figueroa (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Rollie Fingers (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Ross Grimsley (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Larry Gura (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Burt Hooton (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fergie Jenkins (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tommy John (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Dennis Leonard (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Marshall (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), J.R. Richard (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Don Robinson (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Paul Splittorff (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bob Stanley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Kent Tekulve (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1979	Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tommy John (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Kern (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jerry Koosman (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Aurelio Lopez (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Marshall (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Joe Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), J.R. Richard (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Kent Tekulve (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1980	Jim Bibby (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Larry Gura (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tommy John (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tug McGraw (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Scott McGregor (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Joe Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Norris (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jerry Reuss (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Steve Rogers (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Joe Sambito (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1981	Britt Burns (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Steve Carlton (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Larry Gura (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Dennis Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Steve McCatty (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Nolan Ryan (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Pete Vuckovich (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
1982	Joaquin Andujar (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bill Caudill (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Gene Garber (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Greg Minton (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dan Petry (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Steve Rogers (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Bob Stanley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rick Sutcliffe (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Fernando Valenzu (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Geoff Zahn (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
1983	Richard Dotson (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Al Holland (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Scott McGregor (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Craig McMurtry (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Larry McWilliams (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jesse Orosco (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Steve Rogers (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Nolan Ryan (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Lee Smith (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bob Welch (NL (Voting Rank: #8))
1984	Joaquin Andujar (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Boddicker (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Rich Gossage (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dan Petry (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Frank Viola (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
1985	Doyle Alexander (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Joaquin Andujar (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tom Browning (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Britt Burns (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Orel Hershiser (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Charlie Leibrand (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Donnie Moore (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Moore (AL (Voting Rank: #10)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jeff Reardon (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), John Tudor (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fernando Valenzu (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1986	Ron Darling (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mark Eichhorn (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Sid Fernandez (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Teddy Higuera (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Krukow (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bob Ojeda (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rick Rhoden (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Righetti (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Fernando Valenzu (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Witt (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1987	Doyle Alexander (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Orel Hershiser (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Teddy Higuera (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jimmy Key (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mark Langston (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Jeff Reardon (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Rick Reuschel (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Nolan Ryan (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Scott (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rick Sutcliffe (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Frank Viola (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Bob Welch (NL (Voting Rank: #8))
1988	Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), David Cone (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mark Gubicza (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Bruce Hurst (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Danny Jackson (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
1989	Jeff Ballard (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tim Belcher (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mike Bielecki (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Scott Garrelts (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Orel Hershiser (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Joe Magrane (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Moore (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Gregg Olson (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Rick Reuschel (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Jeff Russell (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Scott (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mitch Williams (NL (Voting Rank: #9))
1990	Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Chuck Finley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ramon Martinez (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Randy Myers (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bobby Thigpen (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Frank Viola (NL (Voting Rank: #3))
1991	Jim Abbott (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Steve Avery (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Andy Benes (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Scott Erickson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bill Gullickson (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Bryan Harvey (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mark Langston (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dennis Martinez (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack McDowell (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jose Rijo (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), John Smiley (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Lee Smith (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Kevin Tapani (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Duane Ward (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mitch Williams (NL (Voting Rank: #6))
1992	Kevin Brown (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Doug Drabek (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jack McDowell (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Charles Nagy (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Lee Smith (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bob Tewksbury (NL (Voting Rank: #3))
1993	Kevin Appier (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), John Burkett (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tommy Greene (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Juan Guzman (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bryan Harvey (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Pat Hentgen (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Randy Johnson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jimmy Key (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Randy Myers (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Mark Portugal (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jose Rijo (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bill Swift (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Duane Ward (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1994	Rod Beck (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Doug Drabek (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), John Franco (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Marvin Freeman (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ken Hill (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Danny Jackson (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Randy Johnson (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jimmy Key (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bret Saberhagen (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Lee Smith (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1995	David Cone (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Ramon Martinez (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jose Mesa (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Charles Nagy (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Hideo Nomo (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Pete Schourek (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Tim Wakefield (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1996	Andy Benes (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jeff Fassero (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Alex Fernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roberto Hernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Ken Hill (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Al Leiter (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Charles Nagy (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Denny Neagle (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Hideo Nomo (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Shane Reynolds (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Todd Worrell (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1997	Randy Johnson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Darryl Kile (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Randy Myers (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Denny Neagle (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Brad Radke (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Curt Schilling (NL (Voting Rank: #4))
1998	Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), David Cone (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Randy Johnson (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Al Leiter (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), David Wells (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1999	Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Bartolo Colon (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), David Cone (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Keith Foulke (AL (Voting Rank: #10)), Freddy Garcia (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mike Hampton (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Roberto Hernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #10)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jose Lima (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Kevin Millwood (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jamie Moyer (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Aaron Sele (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Billy Wagner (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), John Wetteland (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
2000	Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Tim Hudson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Todd Jones (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Darryl Kile (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Robb Nen (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), David Wells (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
2001	Freddy Garcia (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tim Hudson (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jon Lieber (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Matt Morris (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jamie Moyer (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mark Mulder (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Curt Schilling (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
2002	Bartolo Colon (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Eric Gagne (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Derek Lowe (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Curt Schilling (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jarrod Washburn (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
2003	Keith Foulke (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Tim Hudson (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Esteban Loaiza (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jamie Moyer (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Russ Ortiz (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mark Prior (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Johan Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Jason Schmidt (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
2004	Eric Gagne (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Randy Johnson (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Brad Lidge (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Joe Nathan (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Carl Pavano (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Francisco Rodrig (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Curt Schilling (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jason Schmidt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ben Sheets (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Carlos Zambrano (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
2005	Mark Buehrle (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Roger Clemens (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Chad Cordero (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jon Garland (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Cliff Lee (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Kevin Millwood (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Johan Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dontrelle Willis (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
2006	Chris Carpenter (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Joe Nathan (AL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Francisco Rodriguez (AL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Kenny Rogers (AL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Takashi Saito (NL (Voting Rank: # 8)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: # 7)), Justin Verlander (AL (Voting Rank: # 7)), Billy Wagner (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Chien-Ming Wang (AL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Carlos Zambrano (NL (Voting Rank: # 5))
2007	Josh Beckett (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Erik Bedard (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Fausto Carmona (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jeff Francis (NL (Voting Rank: # 9)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Cole Hamels (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Aaron Harang (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), John Lackey (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Brad Penny (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Johan Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Jose Valverde (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Justin Verlander (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Brandon Webb (NL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Carlos Zambrano (NL (Voting Rank: # 5))
2008	Ryan Dempster (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Brad Lidge (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Daisuke Matsuzaka (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Francisco Rodriguez (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), C.C. Sabathia (NL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Ervin Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Johan Santana (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Brandon Webb (NL (Voting Rank: # 2))