The Football Cube has stats for all football leagues including NCAA as well as fantasy analysis tools.

Home » Events » Awards » Cy Young Award

» Cy Young Award | History

This page includes history for this award between 1956-2009

Most Recent Winner(s) (2009): Chris Carpenter (NL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Danny Haren (NL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Felix Hernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), C.C. Sabathia (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Javier Vazquez (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Justin Verlander (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Adam Wainwright (NL (Voting Rank: # 3))

TBC Ad Zone

Up To The Minute Minor League Baseball News Check out our daily Top Minor League Performances Report with over 60 of the previous day's top statlines.

Face Value Tickets MLB Baseball Tickets at face value prices. Never get stuck paying scary scalpers again.

The Baseball Prospect Book 2011 by John Sickels. CLICK TO ORDER NOW

. Buy the best baseball bats from DeMarini, Easton and TPX.

Baseball Bargains We offer very low prices on baseball equipment including bats, gloves, and training equipment.

Baseball Equipment Baseball Bats, Softball Bats, Baseball Gloves, Catchers Gear, Wood Baseball Bats, Baseball Hats and Batting Gloves.

Donate 10 to the Cube

Cy Young Award

Year	Award Winners
1956	Whitey Ford (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Sal Maglie (Major League (Voting Rank: #2)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #3))
1957	Dick Donovan (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1958	Lew Burdette (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Bob Friend (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1959	Sam Jones (Major League (Voting Rank: #2)), Bob Shaw (Major League (Voting Rank: #3))
1960	Ernie Broglio (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Lindy McDaniel (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1961	Frank Lary (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Warren Spahn (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1962	Billy Pierce (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Bob Purkey (Major League (Voting Rank: #3)), Jack Sanford (Major League (Voting Rank: #2))
1964	Larry Jackson (Major League (Voting Rank: #2)), Sandy Koufax (Major League (Voting Rank: #3))
1967	Jim Bunning (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Joel Horlen (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fergie Jenkins (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
1969	Dave McNally (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Perry (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1970	Mike Cuellar (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dave Giusti (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Wayne Granger (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Fergie Jenkins (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Sam McDowell (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dave McNally (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Merritt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Carl Morton (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Gary Nolan (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Ron Perranoski (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Gaylord Perry (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Luke Walker (NL (Voting Rank: #10)), Clyde Wright (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
1971	Al Downing (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dick Drago (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dock Ellis (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bob Gibson (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jerry Johnson (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mickey Lolich (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Juan Marichal (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Dave McNally (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Messersmith (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Roberts (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bill Stoneman (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Wilbur Wood (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1972	Steve Blass (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Clay Carroll (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bob Gibson (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Catfish Hunter (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Fergie Jenkins (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mickey Lolich (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Sparky Lyle (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Marshall (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Gary Nolan (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Milt Pappas (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Luis Tiant (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Wilbur Wood (AL (Voting Rank: #2))
1973	Jack Billingham (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Vida Blue (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Ron Bryant (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jim Colborn (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dave Giusti (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), John Hiller (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Catfish Hunter (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Marshall (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fred Norman (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Gaylord Perry (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Wilbur Wood (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1974	Jack Billingham (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Buzz Capra (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Clay Carroll (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Mike Cuellar (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dave Giusti (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Don Gullett (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), John Hiller (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Al Hrabosky (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Fergie Jenkins (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Lynn McGlothen (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Andy Messersmith (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Gaylord Perry (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Luis Tiant (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
1975	Vida Blue (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Rollie Fingers (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Don Gullett (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Al Hrabosky (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Catfish Hunter (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Randy Jones (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Kaat (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Messersmith (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), John Montefusco (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Frank Tanana (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rick Wise (AL (Voting Rank: #8))
1976	Vida Blue (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Bill Campbell (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Steve Carlton (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rawly Eastwick (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mark Fidrych (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Ed Figueroa (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rollie Fingers (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Wayne Garland (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Jerry Koosman (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jon Matlack (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), J.R. Richard (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Don Sutton (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Frank Tanana (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Luis Tiant (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1977	Bill Campbell (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), John Candelaria (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Goltz (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Tommy John (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dennis Leonard (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Rick Reuschel (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dave Rozema (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Frank Tanana (AL (Voting Rank: #9))
1978	Vida Blue (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Caldwell (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ed Figueroa (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Rollie Fingers (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Ross Grimsley (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Larry Gura (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Burt Hooton (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fergie Jenkins (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tommy John (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Dennis Leonard (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Marshall (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), J.R. Richard (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Don Robinson (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Paul Splittorff (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bob Stanley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Kent Tekulve (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1979	Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tommy John (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jim Kern (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jerry Koosman (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Aurelio Lopez (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Marshall (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Joe Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), J.R. Richard (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Kent Tekulve (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1980	Jim Bibby (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Larry Gura (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tommy John (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tug McGraw (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Scott McGregor (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Joe Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Norris (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jerry Reuss (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Steve Rogers (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Joe Sambito (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1981	Britt Burns (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Steve Carlton (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rich Gossage (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Larry Gura (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Dennis Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Steve McCatty (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Nolan Ryan (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tom Seaver (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Pete Vuckovich (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
1982	Joaquin Andujar (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bill Caudill (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Gene Garber (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Greg Minton (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Phil Niekro (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jim Palmer (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dan Petry (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Steve Rogers (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Bob Stanley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rick Sutcliffe (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Fernando Valenzu (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Geoff Zahn (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
1983	Richard Dotson (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Al Holland (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Scott McGregor (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Craig McMurtry (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Larry McWilliams (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jesse Orosco (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Steve Rogers (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Nolan Ryan (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Lee Smith (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bob Welch (NL (Voting Rank: #8))
1984	Joaquin Andujar (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Boddicker (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Rich Gossage (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dan Petry (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mario Soto (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bruce Sutter (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Frank Viola (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
1985	Doyle Alexander (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Joaquin Andujar (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tom Browning (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Britt Burns (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Ron Guidry (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Orel Hershiser (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Charlie Leibrand (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Donnie Moore (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Mike Moore (AL (Voting Rank: #10)), Dan Quisenberry (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jeff Reardon (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), John Tudor (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Fernando Valenzu (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1986	Ron Darling (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mark Eichhorn (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Sid Fernandez (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Teddy Higuera (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Krukow (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bob Ojeda (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Rick Rhoden (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Righetti (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Fernando Valenzu (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Witt (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1987	Doyle Alexander (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Orel Hershiser (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Teddy Higuera (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jimmy Key (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mark Langston (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Jeff Reardon (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Rick Reuschel (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Nolan Ryan (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Scott (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Rick Sutcliffe (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Frank Viola (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Bob Welch (NL (Voting Rank: #8))
1988	Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), David Cone (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mark Gubicza (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Bruce Hurst (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Danny Jackson (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
1989	Jeff Ballard (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tim Belcher (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mike Bielecki (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Bert Blyleven (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Scott Garrelts (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Orel Hershiser (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Joe Magrane (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Moore (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Gregg Olson (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Rick Reuschel (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Jeff Russell (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Nolan Ryan (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Scott (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mitch Williams (NL (Voting Rank: #9))
1990	Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Dennis Eckersley (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Chuck Finley (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Dwight Gooden (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ramon Martinez (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Randy Myers (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Dave Stewart (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dave Stieb (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bobby Thigpen (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Frank Viola (NL (Voting Rank: #3))
1991	Jim Abbott (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Steve Avery (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Andy Benes (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Scott Erickson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Bill Gullickson (AL (Voting Rank: #8)), Bryan Harvey (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mark Langston (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Dennis Martinez (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jack McDowell (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jose Rijo (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), John Smiley (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Lee Smith (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Kevin Tapani (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Duane Ward (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mitch Williams (NL (Voting Rank: #6))
1992	Kevin Brown (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Doug Drabek (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jack McDowell (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jack Morris (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Charles Nagy (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Lee Smith (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bob Tewksbury (NL (Voting Rank: #3))
1993	Kevin Appier (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), John Burkett (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tommy Greene (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Juan Guzman (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Bryan Harvey (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Pat Hentgen (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Randy Johnson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jimmy Key (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Randy Myers (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Mark Portugal (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jose Rijo (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Bill Swift (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Duane Ward (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1994	Rod Beck (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Doug Drabek (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), John Franco (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Marvin Freeman (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ken Hill (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Danny Jackson (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Randy Johnson (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jimmy Key (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Bret Saberhagen (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Lee Smith (AL (Voting Rank: #5))
1995	David Cone (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Ramon Martinez (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jose Mesa (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Charles Nagy (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Hideo Nomo (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Pete Schourek (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Tim Wakefield (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1996	Andy Benes (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jeff Fassero (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Alex Fernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roberto Hernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Ken Hill (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Al Leiter (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Charles Nagy (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Denny Neagle (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Hideo Nomo (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Shane Reynolds (NL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Todd Worrell (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
1997	Randy Johnson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Darryl Kile (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Randy Myers (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Denny Neagle (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Brad Radke (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Curt Schilling (NL (Voting Rank: #4))
1998	Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), David Cone (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Randy Johnson (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Al Leiter (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), David Wells (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
1999	Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Bartolo Colon (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), David Cone (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Keith Foulke (AL (Voting Rank: #10)), Freddy Garcia (AL (Voting Rank: #9)), Mike Hampton (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Roberto Hernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #10)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jose Lima (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Kevin Millwood (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jamie Moyer (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Aaron Sele (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Billy Wagner (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), John Wetteland (AL (Voting Rank: #6))
2000	Kevin Brown (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roger Clemens (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Tom Glavine (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Tim Hudson (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Todd Jones (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Darryl Kile (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Greg Maddux (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Robb Nen (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), David Wells (AL (Voting Rank: #3))
2001	Freddy Garcia (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Tim Hudson (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Jon Lieber (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Matt Morris (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jamie Moyer (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mark Mulder (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Curt Schilling (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
2002	Bartolo Colon (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Eric Gagne (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Derek Lowe (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Curt Schilling (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jarrod Washburn (AL (Voting Rank: #4))
2003	Keith Foulke (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Tim Hudson (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Esteban Loaiza (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Jamie Moyer (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Russ Ortiz (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mark Prior (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Johan Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Jason Schmidt (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
2004	Eric Gagne (NL (Voting Rank: #7)), Randy Johnson (NL (Voting Rank: #2)), Brad Lidge (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Pedro Martinez (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Joe Nathan (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Carl Pavano (NL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Francisco Rodrig (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Curt Schilling (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Jason Schmidt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Ben Sheets (NL (Voting Rank: #8)), Carlos Zambrano (NL (Voting Rank: #5))
2005	Mark Buehrle (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Roger Clemens (NL (Voting Rank: #3)), Chad Cordero (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Jon Garland (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Cliff Lee (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Kevin Millwood (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: #4)), Andy Pettitte (NL (Voting Rank: #5)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Johan Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Dontrelle Willis (NL (Voting Rank: #2))
2006	Chris Carpenter (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Trevor Hoffman (NL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Joe Nathan (AL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Roy Oswalt (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Francisco Rodriguez (AL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Kenny Rogers (AL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Takashi Saito (NL (Voting Rank: # 8)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: # 7)), Justin Verlander (AL (Voting Rank: # 7)), Billy Wagner (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Chien-Ming Wang (AL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Carlos Zambrano (NL (Voting Rank: # 5))
2007	Josh Beckett (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Erik Bedard (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Fausto Carmona (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Jeff Francis (NL (Voting Rank: # 9)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Cole Hamels (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Aaron Harang (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), John Lackey (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Brad Penny (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Johan Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), John Smoltz (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Jose Valverde (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Justin Verlander (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Brandon Webb (NL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Carlos Zambrano (NL (Voting Rank: # 5))
2008	Ryan Dempster (NL (Voting Rank: # 6)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), Brad Lidge (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Daisuke Matsuzaka (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Mike Mussina (AL (Voting Rank: #6)), Mariano Rivera (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Francisco Rodriguez (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), C.C. Sabathia (NL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Ervin Santana (AL (Voting Rank: #7)), Johan Santana (NL (Voting Rank: # 3)), Brandon Webb (NL (Voting Rank: # 2))
2009	Chris Carpenter (NL (Voting Rank: # 2)), Roy Halladay (AL (Voting Rank: #5)), Danny Haren (NL (Voting Rank: # 5)), Felix Hernandez (AL (Voting Rank: #2)), C.C. Sabathia (AL (Voting Rank: #4)), Javier Vazquez (NL (Voting Rank: # 4)), Justin Verlander (AL (Voting Rank: #3)), Adam Wainwright (NL (Voting Rank: # 3))